What Do We Think About Britain's Missing Top Model?

Posted by Brian Fairbanks

 

Our first reaction was three words: a new low. But the more we think about the BBC's latest model reality show, premiering Tuesday night, the more we think it may be a largely positive idea...

The show, which is obviously a takeoff of America's Next Top Model, is unfortunately called Britain's Missing Top Model, which you would think means it's a detective show with the English version of Hayden Panettiere or something. Nope-- instead, it features

a woman whose arm was severed in a bus crash, another who is profoundly deaf and an aspiring film director who suffers from a degenerative neuro-muscular disorder, which means she is largely confined to a wheelchair. [News.com.au]

Great, promoting disability awareness by putting the cattiest girls alive in one apartment together? Once again, our assumptions seem to be incorrect:

Anyway, the title’s not the only baffling element of Britain’s Missing Top Model. To be frank, Britain’s Missing Top Model is a mess, and it all boils down to one, elemental problem: no lunatic sassy bitches. [Times UK]

Apparently, the producers put together mature, thoughtful, good-looking disabled women for the show-- there's no fighting or other fake drama on this show. Even so, are the producers still exploiting them for profit in the cruelest way or actually trying to have a decent reality show that presents the disabled in a positive light (i.e. "we can be cool and good looking, too" or whatever)?

What do you think?  


Comments

xntricpunk said:

whether or not the producers may be trying to exploit the "freak show" aspect is irrelevant, i think. it really all depends on how the show is interpreted by its viewers who, in turn, are influenced largely by media treatment of the shows they watch. i'm sure the producers would probably rather the show be seen as a source of inspiration and education but their primary concern is more likely that the show be seen period. hopefully they won't have to resort to low-road advertising schemes to attract viewers.

June 30, 2008 3:19 PM

derek said:

you suck

June 30, 2008 4:44 PM

nederick said:

To say that the producers are exploiting the women would be to imply that because of their disabilities, these women are less able to make their own decisions or are somehow powerless by virtue of their physical limitations, a sentiment I doubt they would appreciate.

June 30, 2008 6:48 PM

About Brian Fairbanks

Brian Fairbanks, the Senior National Political Correspondent for Nerve, is a filmmaker living in Brooklyn or New Orleans, depending on the season. He is a heavily-armed advocate of gun control.

in