DISPATCHES

Question IV
The Catholic Church continues to stand by its distinction between "natural" sex (heterosexual, married) and "unnatural" sex (homosexual, outside the sanctity of marriage) in a time when society is becoming increasingly accepting of "alternative" lifestyles. Do you think the Church is becoming any more or less tolerant? Should it by definition not be tolerant? Will unwavering commitment to this stance lead to an eventual decline in the authority of the Church? Or would altering the doctrine as it applies to contraception, female and gay priests, abortion, gay marriage and masturbation be an invitation to contumacy throughout the whole of the religion?




Frances Kissling

As I read through this Nerve VoiceBox, I felt some uneasiness. Perhaps my familiarity with the work of the authors and the fact that the questions were somewhat focused on history were at odds with my experience at the United Nations where governments, including the Vatican, are to this day still debating sexual and reproductive health rights, the value and dignity of women, and adolescent sexuality — and coming up with the same old damaging answers.
     What about the fourteen women I met with in the slums of Santiago, Chile, each of whom told me all of their children were conceived in marital rape? Or the twenty or so anti-sex, so-called pro-lifers who converged last week on a SIECUS panel at the United Nations, priest in tow; in response to the assertion that one value of sexuality was honesty, the priest, red-faced and angry, demanded to know what studies showed that honesty was an ethical norm!
     At this point, affecting real change here and now is as important as understanding the past. Why are so many Catholics, indeed so many Christians, so silent in the face of continued harmful sexual teachings? Why has no one articulated a truly open and honest alternative vision of a sexual ethic that serves people?
     Camille's atheism aside, what does God care about when it comes to sexuality?
Introduction

Question I
Camille Paglia
Thomas Moore
Elaine Pagels
Robert Francoeur
Frances Kissling

Question II
Camille Paglia
Thomas Moore
Elaine Pagels
Robert Francoeur
Frances Kissling

Question III
Camille Paglia
Thomas Moore
Elaine Pagels
Robert Francoeur
Frances Kissling

Question IV
Camille Paglia
Thomas Moore
Elaine Pagels
Robert Francoeur
Frances Kissling

Question V
Camille Paglia
Thomas Moore
Elaine Pagels
Robert Francoeur
Frances Kissling




©1999 Frances Kissling and Nerve.com
promotion
buzzbox
partner links


advertise on nerve | affiliate program | home | photography | personal essays | fiction | dispatches | video | opinions | regulars | search | personals | horoscopes | NerveShop | about us |

account status
| login | join | TOS | help

©2009 Nerve.com, Inc.