Dear Miss Information,

I'm a twenty-something heterosexual male, and I'm still a virgin. Every romantic advance I've ever made on a woman has been thoroughly rebuffed, and about four years ago I just gave up entirely, accepting the likelihood that I would die a virgin. I decided that the traits women are looking for — good looks, alpha-male personality, and financial security — are things I just don't and most likely never will possess. To be honest, I now feel like peers in my age group are so much more sexually experienced than me that I would be viewed as completely inept sexually. I'm now terrified of the prospect of physical intimacy.

In the past year or so, however, I've started having some disturbing and persistent sexual fantasies and dreams that I can't seem to control. In these fantasies I'm raping or otherwise sexually assaulting women. At first the fantasies and dreams were infrequent, so I didn't worry too much. In the past few months, however, they've become a daily and nightly occurrence. What especially freaked me out was when I caught myself considering what resources would be needed to build a secure, hidden rape dungeon in my house.

I feel terrible about myself. The fact that I can't stop these fantasies makes me feel no better than predators I abhor. I have no plans to act out any of these fantasies, but I fear that if I don't get them in check soon I may become the worst sort of person.

I'm worried that my involuntary celibacy may be triggering these fantasies. I've thought about hiring a prostitute or seeing a sex therapist, but I have the money for neither. Is the human sex drive so strong as to turn an otherwise normal, functioning member of society into a rapist?  Time Bomb

Dear Time Bomb, 

I'm not going to get into advanced rape theory. I'll leave that to Nerve's overeducated and astoundingly brainy group of commenters. I will say that the motivation has been the subject of debate since forever and a Betty White ago. Theories range from evolution (Darwin made me do it) to childhood gender socialization (Hot Wheels made me do it) to rape culture (Maxim made me do it) to drugs and alcohol (Jack Daniels made me do it and also this enormous blunt). It's an incredibly complex issue, and "Will you or won't you become a rapist?" is not a question I can answer in this column.

But I can attempt to challenge some of your preconceptions, the first being that you're a hopeless case at the tender age of twenty-something years old. Comedy badass Tina Fey was twenty-four years old when she lost it. Brazilian supermodel Adriana Lima was almost thirty. I doubt you'd kick either out of bed.

Up next, these "traits women are looking for." Good looks, I'll give you. But bear in mind that's incredibly subjective. For every woman who finds you unappealing, there's another who thinks you're hot stuff. This "alpha-male personality?" Applesauce. It sounds like someone's been reading too much pickup-artist methodology and USA Today pop science. Be careful with that stuff. It'll rot your brain. As for financial security, sure, it's nice, but a requirement? Looking on a macro level (women are closing the wage gap and even pulling ahead) as well as on a personal level (I've consistently earned more than the men I've dated for close to a decade now), I'd say the answer is no. Finally, does having more partners make you a better lover? Not always. I'd rather take my chances with you than with a guy whose last girlfriend condoned slobbery ear licking. 

Now that I've questioned some of your core truths, I have to say that I'm not too worried about these so-called "deviant" thoughts. I think your insecurities and imagination are conspiring to fuck with your sense of self. I don't know how much you know about Obsessive Compulsive Disorder, but your problem sounds textbook.  

From WebMD: "Symptoms of the disorder include obsessions. These are unwanted thoughts, ideas, and impulses that you have again and again... They get in the way of your normal thoughts and cause anxiety or fear. The thoughts may be sexual or violent." 

From the National Institute of Mental Health: "Some common obsessions include having frequent thoughts of violence and harming loved ones, persistently thinking about performing sexual acts the person dislikes..." 

OCD, if that's what you have, is treatable. There are medications, self-help manuals, and doctors. Sometimes just recognizing what it is, reading up on it, and learning some control techniques is enough to relieve it in its mild forms. 

I know you say you can't afford a shrink, but I encourage you to rethink that. You pay your taxes like everyone else and you deserve whatever free services you've got coming to you from the government. If you earn too much to qualify, then you need to start prioritizing. People always have money for what feels comfortable but are suddenly broke when it comes to that which scares them. Do you want peace of mind or Call of Duty 4?

Dear Miss Information,

I am separated and waiting for a divorce from my husband, who turned out to be a serial cheater. Although I am moving on emotionally, my ego is bruised. One silver lining is that I am bisexual and excited at the chance to date a woman. My experience in that realm is limited, but the one meaningful, ongoing encounter I've had was great. I put up a Nerve profile in hopes of meeting a lady, and it's been a few months now with only one response! I met my husband on here, and used to get messages from men all the time when I was single. Perhaps I don't know how craft a profile to attract a woman, or maybe women just don't find me attractive? My profile is very "me," and I don't like the idea of putting something fake out there. Is there something wrong with my profile that I'm not seeing? — The Girl That Apparently No One on the Planet Wants to Date 

Dear Girl That No One Wants to Date, 

I checked out your profile. I'd certainly get with you, if that means anything. Even turning off my redhead-equals-triple-fuckpoints dirty-Scrabble bonus, you've got good pictures and intelligent responses. You're homey but not matronly. Cultured but not an advanced-literary-theory-spouting jackass. Sexy but not sleazy.  Two fixes I'd suggest: 

1. Change your status from "Separated" to "Single." I know you don't want to be fake, but the truth is that many people will see that word and use it as an excuse to move on. They won't understand that there's no way in Hades you're going back to your ex-husband and are just waiting for the paperwork to process. It's better to let them get to know you a little, see what a standup gal you are, and then make the full disclosure. Note that I'm not talking about the seventh date. I'm talking first or second date, tops. To those who say that's unethical, I say lighten up. There are people who hide spouses, children, and more. Bending the truth a little to widen your applicant pool is not going to permanently scar anyone. 

2. Your face. I can't see it very well. I can see your bod, which is aces. Maybe get some more head-focused shots? I don't know if you're trying to maintain the illusion of privacy, but if you are, you may as well get over that right now. There is no shame in online dating. If you do it, people are going to find out. Chances are, the girl next to you at work is on the same site, as is the guy the next row over. Would you rather they see you looking like a regular person, or like an anonymous victim on a Russian escort site?

The final advice is to contact people. Women, especially the bi-to-straightish type you're going for, are used to men contacting them. It may not be gender equity, but it's reality. Spend some credits. Write some letters. Take some time to craft some custom responses. The divorce is a no-no. Clever banter is a yes-yes.

Consider whether you want to be on more than one site. Most people have a few they're on at once. Sometimes the action ebbs and flows. One site will be hot one week, another the next. It's an inexact science. Don't forget about alternate non-dating sites like Meetup.com and community boards on bisexual websites. Just Google your town + bisexual and you're on your way to Girlville. 

Readers, any tips on approaching gay and bisexual women online? Do you think our redheaded letter writer should use a different approach than she would if pursuing a guy, or is it all the same?

Have a question? Email erin@nerve.com. Letters may be edited for length, content and clarity.

Commentarium (20 Comments)

Jun 21 10 - 1:41am
ab

I think clear face shots are important. Without them, people might perceive that you either don't like your looks or that there's something "wrong" with your face. Either way, it isn't a draw. I agree with Erin that you should change your status to "single" -- "separated" suggests a) too much baggage! b) a general state of wishy-washyness; the word itself suggests that you are still tied to your husband and perhaps more likely than not to repair the relationship. I wouldn't contact anyone with this status; without having met the person and thus not being able to weigh good qualities against perceived problems or hang-ups, there's simply no reason not to pass you by and find someone single. Just saying.

Jun 21 10 - 1:53am
julie

As someone who's had a similar experience to the second writer (plenty of messages from men, few from women), I'd emphasize that same-sex interactions mean that you're going to have to send messages even if you're used to men making the first approach. Also, keep in mind than non-heterosexuals simply make up a smaller percentage of the population-- you may have to make some of your requirements more lax or expand the geographic area you're looking at to find the right person. Good luck!

Jun 21 10 - 3:00am
Name

In response to number one- get your head checked. First. Then, find a partner or get found. I fit the description (flat-broke, Egon Schiele physique, Jack Nickelson face, beta-male) of a total weirdo and I have a date w/ a model Tuesday night. Hold on and do no harm.

Jun 21 10 - 9:39am
mpb

For LW 1, it's also worth considering how you approach women. It's tough--I'm a girl, but I know that from my male friends, and my own experience being hit on. A guy who seems desperate or needy is a turn-off, even if he's super hot. On the other hand, a nerdy sunken-chested coke-bottle-glasses-wearing bloke who is happy, intelligent, and witty will get my attention. Triple bonus points if you can dance. My boyfriend is heavy (okay, actually kinda fat), wears unflattering glasses, and had really low self esteem when I met him. It's mean, but I probably wouldn't have given him a second glance. But oh my can that man dance. And that suddenly made him sexy to me. Check out partnered dance classes. You rarely have to be a couple, women tend to outnumber men, and you'll learn a skill that can get you laid.

Jun 21 10 - 11:45am
M

To the first letter, I would not worry so much. This is coming from someone who is a constant worrier - I know how much it sucks. I've had similar thoughts, although not sexual in nature, but more violent and it scares me as well. Like the person in the letter, I would never do any of these things, but they will come across my mind and I'll FREAK OUT. Generally, I've discovered that these thoughts are just covering up insecurities and real anxieties.

I dunno how to advise the person in the first letter, but know that it isn't unusual or awful to have those feelings, and that you aren't alone. Good luck!

Jun 21 10 - 12:10pm
TenarGoha

The first letter freaks me out a little. It sounds to me like he's got some latent anger at women for not fucking him and now it's expressing itself throug these violent fantasies. All the stuff about how women are into "alpha males" and "financial security" is a tip-off. Guys who basically see women as gold-digging idiots who just want rich assholes who will dominate them don't ever NOT have issues with women. Maybe that's why women ran so far away from him. We can often pick up on these things.

this guy needs to get himself to a shrink and fast. It sounds like the good guy that's in him is starting to get alarmed by the encroaching creepy guy and that's why he wrote this letter. He'd better get some help for the good guy or, one day, the creepy guy fantasizing about rape dungeons might be all that's left. The time to do it is now, when he's still young. Because Erin is right, it's not as unusual as many think to not have sex until your 20s. And experience does not necessarily a good lover make. But not having sex sounds like just the tip of the iceberg with this guy. Get yourself sorted, bud. Do it for yourself and do it for women too. The world does not need another angry, embittered, misogynist loner. Don't turn into one.

Jun 21 10 - 12:39pm
Nonymous

I remember when I thought I would die a virgin. And then all those years youth and testosterone made me miserable and insatiable. With time and experience things have improved. At 46 I'm dating the sexiest, kindest woman I know.

Get out of the house. Nothing interesting ever happens at home.
Become the person you want to date. Nourish your mind, body, and spirit.
Find something you enjoy doing. There will be women there. They will see you enjoying yourself and think, "How can I get some of that?"

Jun 21 10 - 12:44pm
scram

The first letter makes me sad and a little uneasy, but I don't agree entirely with the above comment. Is the shrink the answer? Probably. But a female friend would help and a sense of self awareness. I've been really into dudes who were not necessarily attractive because they carried themselves in a certain way. There's no need to give up or give in to anything. Sort yourself out and the rest will follow.

Jun 21 10 - 1:43pm
Cynthia

LW1: Rape fantasies are not in and of themselves an indicator that you'll act on them. There are people who have incredibly deep fantasy lives of things that they would never do or want to do, and they understand that their fantasies are just that: fantasies. There are others who do indeed get involved in scenarios involving humiliation, forced acts, bondage, etc --- but they are all role-played scenarios, as in, **not real.** They're play-acting, and the scenes and roles are negotiated and discussed in advance by consenting adults, with all parties having pre-arranged safewords to allow themselves to exit the situation at any time. Lots of people enjoy fantasy role-play and understand that just because they like to pretend to be the bad babysitter forced to _______ the daddy doesn't mean they actually want to go get a babysitting job and _____ the dad. It's a **fantasy**.
(More in next comment.)

Jun 21 10 - 1:43pm
Cynthia

All that said, I do think you need to find a therapist, because some things are clear: a) you talk in vast generalizations of what "women" want, using dated stereotypes of "alpha male" and "financial security". I'm going to make an educated guess that you don't know very many real women very well. Worse, there's no small amount of misogyny in the stereotypes you hold up as truths. (I'm not saying that *you* are a misogynist, just that some of your ideas are.) And b) you have built up a lot of fears and anxieties that are now so entrenched you take them as truths: "No one will want me," etc. These are things that will, indeed, make it hard for you to form real attachments to women. You should make it a priority to find yourself a therapist who will help you work on this. And make sure that your therapist is sex-positive and will understand that your fantasies do not necessarily and automatically mean that you want to harm women; instead, you want someone who will patiently help you sort all of this out.
Don't just expect this to get better on its own; it may, but only partially. And don't feel shame about seeking therapy; if you need help, you should ask for it.
Best of luck.

Jun 21 10 - 1:49pm
ROD

Funny how no one mentions that the virgin gentleman should see "Professionals" to alleviate his virginity problem.
Whatever rationalization you might be able to make up, a sexually frustrated man is prone to violence. Keep giving useless advice if you want the next George Sodini.
Easiest advice, find a good professional and employ her services. The end.

Jun 21 10 - 3:55pm
TenarGoha

@ Cynthia. I pretty much agree with everything you said. Right on!

@ ROD--"Whatever rationalization you might be able to make up, a sexually frustrated man is prone to violence."

Well that's a rationalization if I ever heard one. A sexually frustrated man--or, get this, WOMAN--is prone to extreme crankiness. That's hard to dispute. Violence is something different altogether and it's not the inevitable result of a guy not getting his rocks off. (Although, that being said, as I've already stated, this letter writer creeps me out a bit.)

And if you are talking about rape in particular, please research actual rape more. Because most men don't do it because they're "sexually frustrated." Rape =/=sex.

I'm not necessarily against the guy seeing "professionals", although I think a sexual surrogate would be a much better idea than a prostitute. But even if he decides to go this route, I think it should be in addition to, not instead of, finding a good nonjudgmental therapist.

Jun 21 10 - 9:14pm
cheesecake

My fiance didn't have a girlfriend until he was 26, lived in another country, and had some confidence-building, non-sexual adventures. He's slept with just a handful of women, and he's FANTASTIC in bed. Oh, and I suffer from Seasonal Affect Disorder, and I can always feel it coming on with the uncontrollable violent fantasies. A couple trips to the doctor and twenty dollars worth of meds a month relieves me of them when they grow too frequent and disturbing. Doing something about it takes some cash, but it is worth it.

Jun 21 10 - 11:07pm
Lisa

I agree with many posters above that not every woman wants the hot, rich, alpha-male. In fact, that's the exact type of man I tend to avoid. I find myself drawn to normal-looking, meek, artistic types. Whatever you are like, there are women out there who see you as their ideal. Also, there are women out there who would love to "educate" a virgin. I'd recommend putting up some ads requesting de-virginization on sites like Adult Friend Finder or Craigslist. I have a feeling you'll find a non-professional who will be happy to make you her sex toy for free.

Jun 22 10 - 11:49pm
Sarah Ma

Wow...a twenty something year old male virgin? I didn't think they existed anymore. LOL.

I think you need to be more aggressive. I wrote about it on my blog....here you go.

http://sexandloveblog.com/my-blog/Sarah%20M/profile.html

Jun 23 10 - 1:35am
Bart

Letter #1: Dude needs a shrink and a membership to Alt.com. He'll find petgirls who will swoon over a virgin dude who wants to role play rape.

Letter #2: Does her profile identify her as lesbian or bisexual? If it says bisexual she should change it to lesbian, because a lot of lesbian run far and fast from bisexual identified girls.

Jun 25 10 - 1:17pm
Flynn

@ROD - I think there's something really wrong with you if you think seeing a prostitute is the proper way to teach an inexperienced person how to form healthy relationships with women. What the hell? Every woman forward he'll treat as a commodity. I have nothing against sex workers but this isn't the time or place.

Jun 25 10 - 1:33pm
kr

lack of sex doesnt turn you into a rapist. ive had dry stretches that lasted years, and am currently in one of those stretches now.

Jun 25 10 - 5:57pm
MW

#1 -- I agree with Cynthia and TenarGoha.

#2 -- yeah, your three biggest problems are "separated", "bisexual", and passivity.

Jun 26 10 - 7:06pm
steve

Letter #1: Rape fantasies can simply be about power (which this guy seems to feel like he lacks in real life), and/or finding a more intense release for intense feelings of frustration. I'd suggest that he read up on BDSM and learn that there are healthy and satisfying ways to play out power dynamics in real life. Safe, sane, and consensual is the rule.