Savage Love

The female orgasm according to Dan.

By Dan Savage

I am a twenty-three-year-old female, sexually active for seven years, and I can’t reach climax. I am extremely frustrated. I have a wonderfully patient and helpful partner. He has tried hard to no avail. I can’t even get myself there. I feel like I am broken. My partner and I talk out anything that is bothering me, we try different things, but no matter what the situation, I can never reach orgasm. When I went off birth control, I brought up to my doctor that I had never had an orgasm, and she told me that female orgasms are largely a mental thing. She suggested I try using fantasy, which was not new to me.

Other than this, my partner and I have a healthy sex life. I don’t know what to do from here. I start to wonder if there is something wrong with me.

— Frustrated Annoyed Person

“FAP certainly shouldn’t feel bad that she doesn’t have a handle on a phenomenon that even sex researchers don’t properly understand,” said Tracy Clark-Flory, who writes informed, fascinating, and sometimes hilarious pieces about sex, dating, and relationships for Salon.com. “In fact, she might be relieved to learn that scientists of all stripes have been struggling for decades to determine why the female orgasm even exists in the first place.”

You might also be relieved to learn about one theory that’s making the rounds, FAP, or… you might not.

“It’s called the ‘byproduct’ theory,” says Clark-Flory, “and it might help make FAP feel less broken.”

Here comes da science:

“Evolutionary selection has hugely favored the male orgasm, for obvious reasons,” explains Clark-Flory, the most obvious being that males who can’t come aren’t going to have many descendants. “The byproduct theory goes that since females share the same embryological origins of pleasure-friendly nerves and tissues as males, women are physically capable of climaxing as well. In this view, the female orgasm is an evolutionary hand-me-down — or, more cynically, lukewarm leftovers.”

In other words…

Every little zygote, so beloved by the GOP base, has all the basic parts needed to build either a male or a female baby who, once born, the GOP base could not care less about. Blasts of hormones transform those pleasure-friendly nerves and tissues — nerves and tissues beloved by the GOP base so long as they remain in the uterus—into either boy junk or girl junk. Backers of the byproduct theory believe that women are capable of having orgasms not because women need to have orgasms, but because female junk is built from the same component parts as male junk. Women can have orgasms because men must.

“At first, I found this theory terribly off-putting,” says Clark-Flory, “but I would encourage FAP to think about it differently, as I eventually did.”

Viewing the female orgasm as an “evolutionary freebie,” Clark-Flory continues, “can actually validate the vast range of women’s orgasmic experiences, as Elisabeth Lloyd, author of The Case of the Female Orgasm, has argued. This means a multiorgasmic woman is just as ‘normal’ as an orgasmless one, a lady who comes from a single flick of the finger is just as ‘healthy’ as one who requires forty-five minutes with her Hitachi Magic Wand set on high.”

So you’re not “broken,” FAP, even if you’re not orgasmic.

Clark-Flory doesn’t think you should give up all hopes of ever experiencing an orgasm — nor do I! — but she thinks you should stop trying so hard and stressing so much.

“When women have a difficult time getting there, it can be helpful to take the finish line away,” says Clark-Flory. “At the risk of sounding woo-woo, I would suggest that she slow down and focus on feeling individual sensations. She’ll be most likely to come when she forgets her worries about all that she isn’t feeling and simply enjoys what she does feel.”

 

CONFIDENTIAL TO EVERYONE: Jamey Rodemeyer — a fourteen-year-old kid growing up in Buffalo, New York — loved Lady Gaga, most of his friends were girls, and he had feminine mannerisms. And for that, he was subjected to daily and often brutal bullying since he was in the fifth grade.

Last week, Jamey took his own life.

“All the girls just loved him and they always defended him,” Jamey’s mother told CBS News. “But all the boys would say, ‘Geez, you’re such a girl. Why are you hanging out with all those girls? What are you, a girl? Oh, you must be gay.’”

For those sins—the sin of hanging out with girls, the sin of loving Lady Gaga, the sin of not being exactly like all the other boys — Jamey had to endure taunts like this one: “I wouldn’t care if you died. No one would. So just do it :) It would make everyone WAY more happier!”

“The bullies are still walking around,” Jamey’s grieving mother told CBS. “They get to wake up tomorrow and go to school and see all their friends, but my son will not be given a second chance.”

Then there’s this detail from the Buffalo News:

“Last September, the It Gets Better Project was launched online as a place for adults [to] reassure troubled and potentially suicidal lesbian, gay, and bisexual youth that despite the taunting, bullying, and physical abuse they face as adolescents and teens, life improves after high school. In May of 2011, Jamey posted [a] YouTube video with the description ‘Jamey From Buffalo, New York telling you, IT GETS BETTER!’”

The It Gets Better Project was created to give bullied and despairing LGBT kids hope for their future. But sometimes hope isn’t enough. Sometimes the damage done by hate and haters is simply too great. Sometimes the future seems too remote. And those are the times that we all feel despair.

Watching Jamey’s It Gets Better video in the wake of his suicide is indescribably heartbreaking. We know now that Jamey was in pain when he made his video. But he was reaching out and trying to help other kids who were suffering.

We can best honor his memory by following his example.

As I’ve said since launching the It Gets Better Project in this space a year ago, nothing about participating in the IGBP excuses or precludes us — the adults among us — from doing more. The videos have helped and continue to help; we’ve heard from thousands of kids and their parents over the last twelve months. Countless LGBT kids have told us that the IGBP provided them with the hope, moral support, insight, and practical referrals to services that they needed to persevere. But we can do more. We can press for the passage of the Student Non-Discrimination Act, we can fight to get anti-bullying programs that address anti-LGBT bullying into the schools, we can support GLSEN and its efforts to get GSAs into every public middle and high school, we can support the Trevor Project and the crucial work it does.

And we can — we must — confront the bigots who are making it worse for kids like Jamey. Whether the bigots are stalking the halls of our schools, running their mouths on cable news, or running for president—the bigots must be confronted and held accountable for the lives they’re destroying.

ABC News reported there may be some accountability in Jamey’s case: “The Amherst Police Department’s Special Victims Unit has said it will determine whether to charge some students with harassment, cyber-harassment, or hate crimes. Police said three students in particular might have been involved.”

Harassment and cyber-harassment don’t become crimes only after the target commits suicide. They’re crimes, period, and they should be investigated and prosecuted before a grieving family has to bury a child, not after.

Jamey’s parents have asked that donations be made in his memory to Crisis Services (www.crisisservices.org). Please donate. And then find something else you can do and go do it.

Then do more.

mail@savagelove.net

Commentarium (34 Comments)

Sep 28 11 - 12:56am
Old Lady

I'm a 47 year old straight woman who finally had her first orgasm last year. Yep, at age 46. I found a LOT of great, very specific advice at Betty Dodson's website. If you haven't heard of her, Google away. I'm sure Dan approves of her. So if any woman in her 20s is still stressing over this, believe me, a) you're not alone and b) I didn't have the damn internet in MY 20s to get advice. You WILL succeed and have a whole lot more happier years than I had.

Sep 28 11 - 1:43am
nope

I hated the response to LW#1. Platitudes, theoretical bio-history and politics instead of any solid advice.

Sep 28 11 - 11:12am
moops

What advice would you give her that she hasn't already tried?

Sep 28 11 - 7:50am
For Yourself

To FAP: along with researching Betty Dodson, get the book For Yourself by Lonnie Barbach. It is a guide to achieving orgasm for females. It helps you learn how to reach orgasm on your own and then gives instruction on how those techniques can be applied to sex with your partner. A lot of women are in your shoes so don't feel bad and don't get discouraged. Best of luck.

Sep 28 11 - 8:02am
BB

Has she tried a Hitachi?

Sep 28 11 - 8:30pm
mb

The reference is to the Hitachi Magic Wand. I agree that, if it hasn't been already, this should be tried post haste, if it hasn't been already. (Note: there is a major difference between a ordinary vibrator and HMW.)

Sep 28 11 - 8:51am
Cynthia

LW1: Are you only trying to reach orgasm when you're with your partner? One obvious step would be to try orgasming alone, and take off the table (at least for the moment) trying to do so when you're with him, as the both of you may be too invested in it right now.
As far as practical advice: Read "Sex for One," by Betty Dodson.

Sep 28 11 - 9:10am
SB

As a teen in the bible belt I went through high school arguing with bigots. I am a straight female, but that never made it ok for someone to verbally abuse one of my gay/transgender peers. Standing up for others made my life more difficult. I couldn't stand the racism, sexism, and overall bigotry that was wildly common at that school. I'm not saying that the South is worse off than any other part of the country, but it sure as hell felt like it then. During my sophomore year, I left that school and entered a homeschooling program. I am happy about my decision, but I know that leaving only helped myself.

Sep 28 11 - 8:21pm
dhr

Giving until you couldn't give any longer is admirable. Helping yourself wasn't wrong--the wrong-doing is entirely with those who drove you away and harassed people you stood up for.

Sep 28 11 - 9:28am
JCF

I've heard one evolutionary explanation for the female orgasm is that it helps suck those spermies up inside faster. But I agree that all the science talk isn't what the letter writer wanted.

Sep 28 11 - 10:25am
Ilsa

I like Tracy Clark Flory but she would not have been my go-to source for this article. Her advice was awful.

Sep 28 11 - 10:48am
dave1976

wrt to the evolutionary stuff, I always assumed the female orgasm existed so that women would have an incentive to actually have sex with us (insert bad joke bad about guy's ignorance of the female orgasm here).

Sep 29 11 - 12:57pm
profrobert

Along those lines, I thought there would be an evolutionary incentive to mate with a man who is interested in the woman's pleasure because he might be more interested in staying around and providing for the family than the wham-bam-thank-you-neanderthal-ma'm guy.

Sep 29 11 - 9:30pm
bob

haha, that would be a really weird thing for a population-level genetic response to develop for that because very few neanderthals ever actually mated with homo sapiens, most homo sapien women did not require an incentive to not fuck neanderthals and vice versa (cause they lived totally separately).

Oct 03 11 - 9:07pm
SC

Jesus Christ, I know this is completely off topic but I just have to respond, what you are describing, bob, is an anthropological theory for the dominance of homo sapiens over neanderthals called the "complete replacement theory," which was the more popular theory for years, for lack of evidence to the contrary and, IMO, cultural reasons based in racism, and is now getting weaker every year and is completely overshadowed by the "assimilation theory," which is that neanderthal genes were simply swamped by the much larger population of sapiens. This is based on recent genetic evidence that previously was unavailable because we did not have enough neanderthal dna. I cannot speak to how much neanderthals payed attention to women's pleasure, but it was probably as variable as sapiens.

Sep 28 11 - 10:53am
Gee

"been struggling for decades to determine why the female orgasm even exists in the first place.” Oh please! Women are human beings, and human beings have sex lives, and orgasms!

Sep 28 11 - 12:26pm
Stu

Sheesh...lotsa hatin' on teh science around here. Trying to answer a "why" question isn't any sort of judgement one way or another. That isn't to say people can't use the answers for malicious purposes, but they can also be used for good. For example, quantum theory enabled the atomic bomb, but also every transistor and semiconductor in existence, including the ones inside the device you're writing your down-with-science statements on. Trying to find out why women can orgasm isn't any more suspect than trying to find out why men have nipples. And the possibility that the answer might be the same one doesn't contain any value judgement at all.

Sep 29 11 - 2:10pm
Gee

It is just something that just should not be questioned, thats all. And please, no one questions why men have nipples. It is a simple fact that is generally known. The same should be for women's orgasms.

Oct 02 11 - 5:04am
Martoukian

Boy, that's sure not true--it gets questioned a lot more than why women do or don't have orgasms.

Sep 28 11 - 2:04pm
nope

@moops: I think within these comments there's some good advice. He could introduce her for good toys for clitoral or g-spot orgasms, good tapes, good books, good stores. Not just "relax and don't think about it."

Sep 28 11 - 2:07pm
Cpt.Douchnozzle

Lame answer this time around and the redeeming quality will be when someone tells me the name of the hottie in the picture so that I may proceed to make sure she knows what a proper orgasm feels like.

Sep 28 11 - 4:52pm
Try this

Perhaps your man friend needs to 'man' up and dominate that precious soul kitchen.

Sep 28 11 - 5:14pm
Kevin

For background on where some of these ideas come from, start with wired.com/wiredscience/2011/09/female-orgasm/ (I can't post a full URL because it permanently goes into "comment under review" purgatory)

Sep 29 11 - 10:44am
HD

FAP - I was 38 before I had my first orgasm because it turns out I cannot orgasm without a very strong vibrator (the Hitachi Magic Wand really is your friend here, as many have said).

I'd recommend getting a variety of toys and start experimenting by yourself so there's no pressure or self-consciousness. You may want to put a thick towel on the bed; when I began playing with vibrators, the start of an orgasm felt like I was going to pee, so I'd stop what I was doing. It just a new sensation that I was misinterpeting as a need to urinate . With a towel there, I felt comfortable enough to keep going -- because no biggie if I did pee on the towel -- and I ended up orgasming instead.

I must be making up for lost time, because now I get myself off 2-3 times a day most days (usually in less than 10 minutes). Take heart!

Sep 29 11 - 11:24am
Greg

Blah blah blah GOP, blah blah blah GOP.
This guy must have the sadest life to be so obsessed with Republicans!
Well, I guess we've won since poor Dan can't live his life without "GOP" popping into his empty head ever five minutes!

Sep 29 11 - 12:28pm
Don

A couple years ago, my wife and I were at a Halloween party as Ellen DeGeneres and Portia DiRossi (I was Portia ... a very ugly Portia in a home-made wedding dress). We had a couple of wife's girlfriends with us, done up as runners-up in the Miss NJ pageant (Miss Secaucus and Miss Newark). I was hanging in the kitchen with the two NJ girls and a couple of the hostesses' housewife neighbors when one of my wife's male coworkers wandered in during halftime, said something like, "Trust [her] to marry a queer." My response was "I'm hanging with these hot women. You'd rather be hanging with the fellas. Your logic. It needs work."

My stepson has since used that same response to deflect some Middle-School agita. Bouncing assumptions back on an aggressor - without being insulting about it - is useful in defusing the immediate situation, plus it may get them to start thinking.

Sep 29 11 - 3:59pm
GeeBee

I dunno Don. Your kid must go to a better school than I did. That response would have got me a sound ass-kicking for the implication that the aggressor might be gay.

Oct 01 11 - 3:02am
Ricochet

Assuming the aggressor even understood what you were saying. Which in my experience is a pretty large assumption.

Oct 01 11 - 10:14pm
A Random Dude

To the first poster: I'm a guy, so my experience is vastly different than yours, and that of course makes anything I write problematic. Also, to play to stereotype, guys are fix-it oriented, and so I guess I'm trying to give you advice on how to fix a problem that most men probably couldn't understand at all, at least on an organic level. So, please pardon me for my ignorance up front.

However, a couple of things. I remember when I first became sexual, at around the age of 11. I would masturbate, but I couldn't really orgasm -- which I suspect probably felt similar to what you may be going through. In fact, later on I found out that I was clenching muscles and, in effect, resisting orgasm rather than allowing it to happen. Now, look, the male body is infinitely simpler than the female in many ways, but I would suspect that you are doing something similar. Weirdly, the problem was that I would "clench" the muscles which would clench and unclench during an orgasm, with the result that I would effectively be able to resist having the orgasm at all. Its much like getting a gas stove so hot and then blowing out the flame, so that re-starting it is very difficult. I know, I know, poor analogy, but what do you want, I'm a testosterone-soaked male. So, what I'm driving at is that maybe you have inadvertantly trained your musculature response to clamp down on your orgasm, when what you need to do is let it breathe.

In my case, I found (yes, at age 11) that there were these exercises that were supposed to help, and you were supposed to do them while doing the rhythmic breathing which mimicked orgasm. The exercises I later found out were called Kegels and they, combined with the rhythmic breathing (and yes, some additional development) eventually resolved the issue. When I did finally have my first orgasm, it was as if the kegels clench-and-releaase began happening on their own (my body essentially turned this from a voluntary to an involuntary response) and my breathing, which I had forced into this pattern, merged into the breathing of an orgasm. Maybe you could try doing Kegels and deep breathing while masturbating, to sort of imprint on your body the first steps of what an organsm would feel like. OK, like I say, I'm a guy, I have different parts, and its been two decades since I went through this, but its something to think about.

The other thing I can say is that, in the last two years, I have tried out the Aneros prostate massager, looking for a new sort of orgasm -- what they call the "Big O." I'm heterosexual, so this is my first time with anything like this. What the Aneros taught me, however, was that the sort of orgasm that it was aiming for was different than the standard male orgasm -- it was something that came more in waves. This seems to be true to me -- when I use it, theres an initial rush of excitement, then sort of a lull, and then another rush, and then a lull, and then another rush, then a lull, with the waves coming closer and closer together until I finally end up over the line into an orgasm.

I'm not saying that this is the same sort of thing that a woman feels, but I imagine that it is similar, since some times no matter how much I want to, I can't force myself to reach that orgasm when using the aneros, while other times I can. But, the reason I mention this is that it has taught me to be more cognizent of these sorts of ups and down while trying to reach orgasm. Is it possible that you are experiencing what I'd describe as an initial excitement, and then a trough, and then a little more excitement, and then another lull, and simply concluding you aren't that into it? In other words, maybe you might try forcing yourself to go a little longer -- not with a lot of pressure on yourself, but just sortof letting it play out and seeing where you end up. In other words, don't look so much for orgasm as a place that you arrive at, but rather, look at it as a description of the entire trip.

Oct 02 11 - 5:09am
Martoukian

We have a tendency to assume women have trouble reaching orgasm because of psychological hangups or fear. But the woman who wrote that letter seems comfortable talking about it and trying with her partner to achieve one. It may be simple physical explanations for her difficulty. Deeper nerve endings, or difficulty reaching the necessary locations, or whatever.

Oct 02 11 - 12:21pm
Leigh

Exactly...What would a Dr know about orgasm's anyway? They spent their whole life in school, work their butts off and get no sleep...When do they have time for sex? lol.

Oct 02 11 - 12:20pm
Leigh

What if I don't believe in evolution? Can I still have an orgasam?

Oct 03 11 - 2:33am
jr

Of course. It won't be "intelligently designed", but you'll still feel it.

Oct 03 11 - 5:16pm
yikes

No.