Pop Torture: The Band of Brothers
Forced March

Prepping for The Pacific, our writer marathons ten straight hours of World War II brutality.
bigiconwide
By James Brady Ryan

Welcome to Pop Torture, a biweekly column in which I embrace my pop-culture masochism and search out the most painful ways to experience the movies, TV, and music that fill our lives with such ecstasy and agony. (Needless to say, I’ll mostly be focusing on the latter.) Each time, I’ll take on a new challenge, and each time I’ll share my adventures with you, provided I survive them.

Challenge: To watch all of HBO's epic, emotionally devastating, ten-hour-plus World War II miniseries Band of Brothers in one sitting.

Readers, I am something of a WWII history buff. While even admitting that much makes me worry I come off like the main character of Apt Pupil, it's true: I may be far from an expert, but give me a book or a movie set during the time period and I'm all over it. So I've seen Band of Brothers before. I even own the DVD set. But, like tequila shots, Band of Brothers episodes should be carefully spaced out. Because, also like tequila shots, if you have too many in a row, you'll be an emotional wreck, sobbing into a comfort foodstuff in a corner somewhere. But in anticipation of the companion miniseries The Pacific, which premieres on HBO on March 14, I've decided to see what happens when you take all ten episodes without a break.

Episode One (9:10 AM)

The theme music itself — and the interviews with real-life WWII vets — can make my eyes water, but I've decided I can't cry until episode three. Since the first episode takes place at boot camp, and features a Friends-influenced performance by David Schwimmer as a sadistic-if-effective captain, I should be safe. It occurs to me, though, that I might have built up a tolerance for this stuff, because while I'm fine throughout, my roommate Meghan and her friend Melissa watch the beginning with me, and quickly set off to find an open liquor store. You'd think they'd never seen obstacle courses covered in pig guts before.

cry1

Episode Two (10:25 AM)

While I stay strong for the theme music, I do get a bit misty when the vets talk about D-Day, this episode's main concern. Old people crying gets to me. This is the first episode to feature detailed and realistic violence, with images apparently designed to hit everyone's soft spots: heights, fire, blood, injured animals, explosions, guns, knives, etc. Even though I've seen this before, the violence is shocking whenever it breaks out. (There are also disturbingly tense silent patches.) But the soldiers — and the girls, who have returned with the goods — don't yet realize how bad it will get, so the tone isn't quite so bleak.

Cry count: one (veterans crying)

Episode Three (11:25 AM)

As this episode progresses, I find myself playing a fun game I call "explain the battle maneuvers to distract myself from the gore." I'm also constantly explaining who is on screen at any given point, since there are over twenty major characters who are all wearing the same thing. I wonder if ignorance is bliss, as Meghan feels a lot worse about seeing Pvt. Tipper suffer a horrifying face wound now that I've explained to her who he is.

Cry count: two (theme music)

Episode Four (12:28 PM)

Me: "Jeez, you can really see the detail in that neck wound."

Meghan: "Give us your laptop. We're going to watch Enchanted in my room."

Episode Five (1:30 PM)

Heading up to the halfway point, the wear and tear is starting to show. When the guns go off, I flinch. When a pile of snow unexpectedly falls off my roof, I shout. When my glass is empty, I start in on my third mimosa. Episode five is when things take a turn from the merely awful to the horrific. Without anyone else to distract me, I am caught between watching the screen (on which the most sympathetic character has just shot a very young German soldier) and dreading what's to come. Luckily, I do get one brief respite: Jimmy Fallon momentarily appears as a supply officer. Dude cannot act, taking me completely out of the moment.

Cry count: three (veterans again!)

cry2

Episode Six (2:23 PM)

A confession: one of the things I like best about Band of Brothers is that every guy — down to the extras — is hot. This version of WWII is strictly fought by eights and above. And so, four mimosas deep, the only thing I have left to get me through an utterly bleak hour is the episode's central character. Or rather, his face. Sadly, this character is also a medic. Imagine yourself in my place: you're admiring his strong cheekbones, his thoughtfully pursed lips, the dark brown of his eyes... and then his forearm probing a man's chest cavity.

Cry count: five (once when a young soldier suffers a particularly awful neck wound, once when a friendly French nurse dies in a bombing)

Episode Seven (3:34 PM)

The problem with a story based on real people is that sometimes characters die in ways that are utterly random, like when Cpl. Hoobler shoots himself in the leg by accident. This is the second episode set during the grueling Battle of the Bulge, a period so desperate and traumatizing it causes one character to dig a foxhole in the frozen ground with his fingers. In turn, I have launched a vicious biting assault on my own fingernails.

Cry count: eight (once for the theme music, once when Hoobler dies, and once when not one but two men lose their legs)

Episode Eight (4:45 PM)

This is the one break in the back five, which are mostly unrelenting. It follows one character returning from hospital who acts like kind of a prat, and Tom Hanks' son as an inexperienced but high-ranked officer also acting like kind of a prat. I use this period of relative ease — which means I have to watch only one soldier scream out "I don't want to die" over and over — to eat a burrito.

Cry count: nine (aforementioned "I don't want to die" incident)

cry3

Episode Nine (5:29 PM)

I'm just going to cut to the chase: in this episode the company liberates a concentration camp. While the crying count is only going to increase by one, this particular instance lasts for literally fifteen minutes.

Cry count: ten (the Holocaust)

Episode Ten (6:21 PM)

What could be so bad about the end of the war, right? For one thing, after over nine hours of an intense WWII miniseries, I could probably shed a tear or two over Dora the Explorer. But here's the other problem with a story about real people: their lives go on after it's all over. And I know this because the end of the episode details the men's lives after the war, all the way up to their deaths. Even the characters who survived? Yeah, they're mostly dead now too. Roll credits!

Final cry count: twelve (once when I hear about how everyone died, once when the veterans talk at the end)

Result: When I mentioned this particular challenge to friends, some people told me it wouldn't count as Pop Torture — for one thing, this is a well-respected piece of television, and for another, I'm on the record as being a fan. And even I wondered if this would be much harder to watch than your average Law & Order marathon. But there's a reason that the first twenty minutes of Saving Private Ryan are only the first twenty minutes, and there's a reason this series was spaced out over ten weeks. To return to my earlier metaphor: ten shots of tequila could be great over two days, not two hours. Which is why I only had four after I finished this challenge.

FIND MORE

Pop Torture: Valentine's Day on Valentine's Day
Ten Former Child Stars You'd Sleep With Today
Ten Profoundly Unsubtle Instances of Movie Product Placement

Commentarium (19 Comments)

Mar 10 10 - 1:47am
Sgt USMC

I watched this while drinking a bottle of scotch one dreary afternoon. Cried like a baby. My Grandfather was in Delta CO of the 512 Paratroopers and I myself was in Iraq. Strange how it all effects you.

Mar 10 10 - 10:24am
rine

james brady ryan, you are my favorite. your crying about wwII made me giggle and i don't care if that's wrong.

Mar 10 10 - 11:34am
Dan

It's a damn good show if it can get you to cry because of the theme music. Ashamed to admit I've only seen the first two episodes.

Mar 10 10 - 12:10pm
John

Damn. I now know what I'll be doing all Saturday afternoon.

Mar 10 10 - 3:08pm
Sticky the Rat

The synopsis for episode 4 says it all. Watching all ten episodes back to back is torture and definitely has to have adverse effects on mental health. That being said (which it was) I really enjoy this column and the writing is fantastic. Keep it up!

Mar 10 10 - 3:34pm

I cried during episode 9. I was home alone so nobody knew.

Mar 10 10 - 3:38pm
TwL

I've seen this series many times, but I don't think I've ever watched more than two episodes in a row. Good stuff.

Mar 10 10 - 3:39pm

the pictures really make this piece. well done!

Mar 10 10 - 5:35pm
Melanie

I love the action shot of you aggressively crying. Sorry if that's wrong. I want to see a concentration camp be liberated!!!

Mar 10 10 - 11:00pm
Felix Jones

Take a spoonful of cement and harden the eff up. They had the marathon on History Channel a few weeks ago. An aside: if you cut to all the combat scenes in Saving Private Ryan it is a really good 40 minute movie.

Mar 11 10 - 5:08am
PO

Yup, right there with you on the tears. Those talking vets get me every time. And that concentration camp scene... when Liebgott has to tell them to go back into the prison? Forget about it.

Mar 11 10 - 11:54am
richharrison

read Winter's Autobio....then you can better understand who he and his men endured the Battle of the Bulge(my former landlord jumped on D-day, was at Bast.(he was captured/excaped from germans 3X)sadly, he's deceased

Mar 12 10 - 11:17am
Runyon

I like how in the midst of 10 hours of WWII carnage, you managed to notice that every man in it is hot haha.

Mar 12 10 - 5:04pm
Rosey

totally with you on the Vets. They get you every time, esp at the end.

Mar 15 10 - 1:00pm
Cubby

Shifty Powers recently died. That made me cry.

Apr 02 10 - 7:23pm
Rachel

I've taken in the entire series in one sitting several times, it's not that bad. But then, I don't often cry in movies and I've never while watching B.O.B. Perhaps I have black heart? Hee hee. Props to you for surviving such a terrible trial.

Apr 03 10 - 9:34am
LSRobb

great column, but you left out one vital cry-inducing scene - when Compton yells for the medic and then drops his helmet in "The Breaking Point" (episode 7). BTW, for me the effect of the music is pavlovian.

Jan 11 11 - 12:02pm
profrobert

Dick Winters died on January 2, aged 92. RIP, Major.

Mar 12 11 - 12:36am
Brooke

Yeah, the medic was super cute. Eugene! But for all the good looking guys on that show, I don't think anyone beats out the real Dick Winters in his youth. Dang.