Not a member? Sign up now
January 30, 2012
Ranked: HBO Dramas from Worst to Best
Which gritty, sprawling, multi-character drama will come out on top?
by David Warner
HBO recently unveiled its newest drama, Luck, which stars Dustin Hoffman, and while it’s a little soon to gauge where it’ll fit in the network’s already-sterling legacy, it got us thinking about that legacy, and where exactly all of our favorite shows fit into it. Is The Wire better than The Sopranos? Is Oz better than Deadwood? Several fistfights later, we still hadn’t settled it. Finally, after an eight-hour meeting that left Editor Alex in the corner muttering about “the horror,” we think we nailed it.
15. K Street (2003)
Steven Soderbergh and George Clooney certainly had an interesting concept on their hands when they came together to produce K Street in 2003; a largely improvised show about a fictional consulting firm that would feature real lobbyists and politicians in DC. At first, it sounded like it could be both entertaining and enlightening. Too bad it was very little of either — turns out Congressman and Senators are boring people. K Street died after one season.
14. John from Cincinnati (2007)
Coming off his primetime hit NYPD Blue and the critical success of Deadwood, David Milch was looking for his next great show. John from Cincinnati wasn’t it. For all its beautiful surfing footage, John from Cincinnati is best remembered for its unlikeable characters and grating faux-mysticism. If the titular John had used his magic powers to pull an interesting plot out of his pocket, they might have had something. Sadly, all he had in there was a bottomless pit of Biblical imagery.
13. Treme (2010-ongoing)
David Simon’s highly anticipated post-Wire show about post-Katrina New Orleans has been lauded nationally (and more importantly, locally in Louisiana) for its authenticity. Simon’s newest creation does achieve an exceptional level of realism. What Treme doesn’t always deliver, though, is compelling drama. Treme is well-shot, well-acted, and well-written, sure. It’s can also be pretty boring — certain storylines just don’t have any emotional resonance or pull to them.
12. Carnivale (2003- 2005)
Like so many HBO dramas before and since, Carnivale wasn’t shy about pushing the envelope. It took full advantage of its subject matter by reveling in the physical oddities of its cast of strange carnies. Unfortunately, it couldn’t push the plot quite as well. Moving at a glacial pace, the show never generated drama as interesting as its imagery. Carnivale was the weirdest, most beautiful, most mind-numbing circus imaginable. Well, after Cirque du Soleil.
11. In Treatment (2008-2011)
Conceptually, In Treatment is unique. So unique, in fact, that HBO still hasn’t figured out how and when to air it, going from five nights a week to two nights, then back up to four. Schedule waffling aside, this is a solid show: watching Gabriel Byrne play one of the worst therapists on television is entertaining enough on a Tuesday or Wednesday night. In fact, if this were a list of almost any other cable network’s original dramas, it would definitely be higher (cough Starz cough). Unfortunately for Dr. Weston, he isn't competing against Spartacus: Blood and Sand.
Commentarium (52 Comments)
Treme deserves a higher ranking...certainly above Carnivale, In Treatment, Rome, Big Love and True Blood. And probably over Six Feet Under.
I agree with everything but Six Feet Under. But that show is just magnificent in my opinion, even for all those Game of Thrones junkies out there. It's better.
~hippie
"Oz" was ridiculous, and doesn't belong anywhere near this high on the list. And "Deadwood" should be at least number 3, if not higher.
Boardwalk Empire is ranked way too high on this list, certainly not top five at all.
Agreed. I watched it for awhile but stopped because it was just so BORING. I never cared about any of the characters.
I like Boardwalk, but in no way is it better than Deadwood. I'd say In Treatment should be 2nd to last because the premise seemed so overwhelmingly boring that myself and many others probably refused to even consider watching a single episode.
Gotta stand up for Boardwalk. If you never made it out of the first season you really missed out. Best show on tv as far as I'm concerned. Stays with you and the characters are phenomenal.
Six Feet Under is waaaaaay too low. And I'd say The Sopranos is too high.
wasn't sex and the city an hbo show?
Yes - an annoying one.
Except for Kristin Davis and her hips. Mmmmmm. Reet petite! Hommina hommina hommina! Voot! Humga, hunga! Halala halala! Nyang nyang! Hubba hubba! Mum-muh-muh-muh-muh-muh-muh-muh! Ottity-ottity-ot! Hot-cha!
Krisin Davis...
The list is top 15 "dramas," so I'm assuming Sex And The City wasn't included because it was more of a sitcom. Same reason Lucky Louie's not on the list...or for that matter, Dream On.
Actually, SATC became a dramedy, then a straight out drama its last few seasons, which may explain just ONEr eason why it sucked ass-and not the good kind, like me sucking Kristin Davis's ass, or Bigs first-second? wife, Bridget Moynihan, MMMM, both of em!
Game of Thrones... such bullshit.
#1 - Sopranos.
Numbers 2 through 4 in some order - Oz, The Wire, Six Feet Under, Deadwood.
Yes, I agree, Game of Thrones should have been #2 behind "The Sopranos".
You guys forgot about the one-season "Tell Me You Love Me." I was OBSESSED with that show.
Couldn't disagree with this list more. Deadwood and Six Feet Under certainly should be higher on the list with Six Feet Under at number one. Oz shouldnt have even made the list. Though I do love Game of Thrones. Carnivale was definitely a guilty pleasure.
It actually sounds like you could disagree with this list more.
No, tmp, Kelley couldn't possibly disagree with this list more than she already does.
I love Tremé, but I can live with the ranking and it's now over yet. Hopefully 3 season is good.
What about Band of Brothers or The Pacific?
Both are a mini-series - that's why they're not included
So was Rome. That's included.
No, Rome ran for two full seasons.
Sopranos first 3 seasons, yes, BEST drama EVER! OZ is and SHOULD be up there-quite ground breaking-and ass breaking too, right, Beecher, lol? Was his and Schillingers bromance one of the small screens greatest love/hate stories?
Six Feet Under deserves to much higher on this list - certainly higher than Boardwalk Empire. It was brilliantly written and the acting was great...not to mention it actually provided an ending in the last episode.
Only problem with Six Feet Under was that it faltered in the last few seasons.
Oz what a great show. If I made the list it would have been number 2 but I am very happy the wire is number one.
Six Feet Under was my all-time favorite show. Definitely deserved a higher ranking.
You definitely got #1 correct, and I don't think that was even debatable. As for the rest of the list, it's pretty subjective. I would put Deadwood and Six Feet Under above Sopranos, but Sopranos was also hurt by repetition and lower quality in its later seasons, whereas Deadwood consists of a few perfect seasons. I think John from Cincinnati gets an unfair amount of criticism and was actually a really cool show with fantastic acting and amazing dialogue. In Treatment looks too stupid to watch so I wold put it next to last.
Pretty decent list, actually. I think Oz and Rome could do to switch places, but I get it that Oz paved the way for all the others, and so it kind of gets the special attention in that regard. I've personally never been as big a fan of the Sopranos as we're all seemingly supposed to be. Maybe if they'd condensed it into 5 seasons it would have been the masterpiece that it really isn't. Not surprised to find it near the top, though.
I agree with the top two choices. Excellent shows.
I can't wait for the next season of Game of Thrones.
Not entirely sure why the writer of this list talks as if the show IN TREATMENT is still on. "So unique, in fact, that HBO still hasn’t figured out how and when to air it, going from five nights a week to two nights, then back up to four."? The show officially had it's last episode back in 2010, and HBO hasn't said it's bringing it back.
Six Feet Under should be top 3. that show was one of the greatest things to ever air on tv, beautiful acting, writing, soundtrack, themes, everything
its INSANE to not have Curb Your Enthusiasm on this list, I'm stunned / shocked
It's INSANE that you don't know the difference between comedy and drama.
*SNAP!*
Booooo! Treme should be higher. It's way ahead of its time. The subsequent pillaging of of Post-Katrina New Orleans still hasn't gotten the attention it deserves. Treme is at least fighting that, and doing a fabulous and heartfelt job doing so. On top of this, they shoot it in NO where they can hire locals, creating jobs.
Treme should be higher!
At first, I was reading this article, and thinking of how much I enjoyed some shows on the list, as well as how I should finally get around to checking out Game of Thrones.
And then I got really really sad that I'd watched every episode of The Wire ever. And basically no show will ever be as good.
Dammit.
Pretty solid ranking. Only comment I have would be that Boardwalk Empire is a little too high and Rome a little too low. Those knocking Oz are crazy. Absolutely loved that series and is perfectly ranked here.
Watched everything but K Street, John from Cincinnati, Treme, and In Treatment, and by the rankings not feeling too bad about it.
Wait, wait, wait!
True Blood is ranked higher than Rome, Treme and Carnivale? Huh? True Blood is incoherent guilty pleasure fodder and no more. It tried to do more in its first season but it's been crap ever since then.
And HOW is Deadwood is lower than Oz and, more importantly, the massively overrated Boardwalk Empire?! In what universe?! Boardwalk Empire can't touch Deadwood in any way, shape or form. Deadwood should be 3rd on this list. Period.
:steps off soapbox while mourning for Deadwood's premature cancellation:
Totally agree with everything you said.
Loved Carnivale and the fact that my publisher has been marketing my book as a forerunner to Carnivale
Elijah Rising
Vampires higher than post-Katrina New Orleans?!?!?!!! I've gotten over the continued trashing of John From Cincinnati, but David Warner, you have proven yourself to be an IDIOT by this sentence about Treme: "certain storylines just don’t have any emotional resonance or pull to them."
Well, what storylines are you referring to? I notice you don't bother to denote them.
I guess trying to recover from the physical and mental trauma brought on by the Katrina and the governmental incompetence that followed isn't enough emotional resonance for you? I guess you don't know anyone from NOLA, or they'd have set you straight on that count. ALL of that show is about people trying to recover, rebuild, reconnect...even if it's not there on the surface, it's lurking below everything that every character does on that show.
It's ok, I bet you think that the movie "The Big Easy" is an accurate reflection of life in New Orleans. And that's why you don't get Treme. Talk to a native New Orleanian and they'll set you straight.
I usually stay off the comments on my own stuff, because I don't like being "that guy," and no matter what points I make here, I'll probably come off as thin-skinned for defending my opinion. But you used my full name and called me an "IDIOT," so here goes.
I don't like Vampires more than post-Katrina New Orleans (for starters, one is a fictional species and the other a city). What this list indicates is that I believe True Blood is a better show than Treme. That is all: one TV show compared to another, True Blood is better.
My point about the story lines not connecting emotionally has to do with craft, not subject matter. A story about struggle in the aftermath of a disaster is important and heart-breaking, sure. If it isn't written well enough, though, it can fall flat on-screen.
And to answer your personal attacks, I went to high school with a number of people displaced by the hurricane, and got to know them fairly well. I don't think they'd be insulted by me not particularly enjoying Treme (again, one TV show).
Bravo David! I might not agree with everything in your ranking order but your rebuttal to that emotional (and completely illogical) argument by 'res' was well said. I for one vote you Non-Idiot Extraordinaire. :-) P.S. Deadwood belongs in the top 3. Just saying.
All the Six Feet Under love... It was so maligned towards the end of its run. Glad people are coming to realize how great it was.
It's Benioff*
Unfortunately, I think it's too difficult to rate current shows against past series. But this series thrives on debate, so maybe that's the idea.
Treme and Deadwood should be higher. Boardwalk Empire? More like Bored-walk Empire, Nucky is not that interesting a character. True Blood is just a big soapy gratuitous mess, not a brilliant show. You got #1 right though :-)
Dexter? Sons of Anarchy? Game of thrones def intop 3 even now.
Seriously? I know this article is a few days old, but I keep being drawn back to your post. How do you not know what channel you're watching? Do you use a remote? What numbers do you punch in? Is there a button called "magic" or "me want favorite shows now"? Do you get lost looking for the couch?
Sopranos deserves to be #1 the Wire #2. The Sopranos changed everything, the pop culture, the mass media, etc.
Not agree, but.. this is like in everything. Opinions
Now you say something