Not a member? Sign up now

13. King of the Hill (1993)
When discussing his films in The Believer, Soderbergh said, "There's a difference between failures and things that are bad. I'd like to think I've made movies that were failures, creatively and otherwise." By his own admission, King of the Hill is one of these failures. The struggle of the adolescent protagonist to survive alone in a hotel is so understated and dull it takes some effort to remind yourself that you're not watching a movie on Nickelodeon. (Play the movie with your eyes closed and tell me the music doesn't sound like something from The Secret World of Alex Mack.)
12. Ocean's Twelve (2004)
Aiming to be nothing more than an entertaining vehicle banking on the success of its predecessor, Ocean's Twelve throws in high-tech gadgets, mindless banter, and Catherine Zeta-Jones, to distract you from the fact that the plot itself is half-baked. Most symptomatic of this fluffiness is a scene where Julia Roberts' character must pose as the real Julia Roberts to help the gang steal a priceless egg, while Bruce Willis (played by Bruce Willis) nags her about his daughter's SpongeBob blanket. Vincent Cassel's excellent performance as a smug master thief is the only thing that keeps your eyes from completely rolling out of your head.
11. Ocean's Thirteen (2007)
The third and final installment of the Ocean's series returns to the glitz and glamor of its Vegas roots, with Soderbergh and co. pulling a wild card and delivering more of a revenge film than a heist film. After their benefactor, Reuben Tishkoff (Elliott Gould), is betrayed by his partner, Willy Bank (Al Pacino), Ocean and his crew develop a scheme to ruin Bank's new casino by rigging its games so the house always loses, implicating every casino player in the process. Shot and edited in a flashy, over-the-top style, the film works as a nice capstone to a series about criminal swagger. But its success is more about its cast and larger-than-life budget than any real craft.

10. The Informant! (2009)
This biographical comedy is carried by Matt Damon's brilliant performance as Mark Whitacre, who blew the whistle on a mid-'90s corporate price-fixing conspiracy. Damon's performance, against a solid story of bureaucratic shenanigans, is more than enough to keep the film moving. His squirming take on the duplicitous Whitacre is both hilarious and sad; he reminds you of a child continuously juggling a lie. Also hilarious is his recurring interior monologue of random facts. Bottom line: watching a man drown in his own dishonesty has never been so much fun.

9. Gray's Anatomy (1996) / And Everything is Going Fine (2010)
It'd be disingenuous to rank one of these two portraits of monologist Spalding Gray over the other, since both are less about filmmaking than about the talents of one of history's greatest raconteurs. Viewed together, the two films are a testament to the art of storytelling, and a visual record of what one man was able to achieve with only his voice (and the occasional glass of water).

8. The Limey (1999)
A Kill Bill for geriatrics, The Limey tells the story of a father (played by the brilliant Terence Stamp) fresh out of British prison who travels to Los Angeles to investigate the death of his daughter. Learning from his mistakes with The Underneath, Soderbergh successfully begins the film in medias res, using an experimental, fragmented editing scheme that cuts the fat from the story. Meanwhile, Stamp carries the film's emotion, with a meditative stare that tells you everything you need to know about the stewing anger and remorse of a failed father. In The Limey, Soderbergh delivered a successful (albeit slim) crime film about revenge and the possibility of redemption.

7. Ocean's Eleven (2001)
With an all-star ensemble cast that both pays homage to and in many ways surpasses the glamor of its Rat Pack predecessors, this remake of the 1960 caper film achieves what every Hollywood film should strive for: a sense of fun with the intelligence to back it up. Soderbergh delivered a stylish heist film that might have toppled under its own weight in the the hands of a lesser director. And while the characters themselves may be more "types" than fleshed-out personalities, the light-hearted humor and wit of the film more than makes up for it. Although Soderbergh made several more interesting films, Ocean's Eleven is nearly perfect in its execution.







Commentarium (81 Comments)
Switch Traffic and Solaris and you're at least close to being accurate.
Agreed. Am I the only one who feels Traffic played more like an after school "very special film" about the idea that drugs are bad?
Traffic is best watched drunk or under the influence of illicit drugs. I saw Solaris at a little art house in New Haven. I remember enjoying it. But Soderbergh is no Tarkovsky. Then again, that's not necessarily a bad thing.
Actually switch Ocean's Twelve and The Girlfriend Experience too. Then I can get behind this list.
Just like you get behind your boyfriend, you shit slingin' savage?
Out of Sight is a wonderful and highly underated film
I think Out of Sight should be #1 on this list. Vastly better than Traffic.
Out of Sight is one of the best films of the 1990s, let alone Soderbergh's best film.
Agreed. Loved Out Of Sight. The pauses in the editing were simply gorgeous.
jhljl
I thought Girlfriend Experience was great - Sasha Gray's deadpan performance seemed a perfection reflection of how her character needed to keep an emotional distance from her john's and heightened her attachment to one of them as well. So personally I think this needs to be bumped way up.
Bingo. I actually like it quite a bit, maybe more than it deserves, but there's certainly no denying a unity between Sasha Gray's acting style and the necessities of her character. Whether she could pull off anything more challenging remains to be seen, but Soderbergh put her icy persona exactly where it belonged and I think he at least deserves credit for that.
I wouldn't go so far to give Sasha Gray credit by saying she has "a style". I think it would have been a more entertaining/interesting movie if you actually felt something for the main character.
I thought Girlfriend Experience was pretty great too (as least far superior to Ocean's 12 and 13...and I love Ocean's 11). Although based on the reviews I read, Sasha Gray's acting was really divisive. You either thought her casting was inspired; or you thought this was nothing but a porn star out of her league. I always wondered how much these reviews were influenced by the respective reviewers' feelings on porn (or perhaps influenced by jealousy, since a porn "slut" was getting the privilege of appearing on screen under the direction of an oscar winning director).
uhh ...She got way too much credit for being good at being vapid. uhh..
Yeah, maybe I had too high of hopes for Girlfriend experience, but her performance didn't do it for me, I guess I really just didn't give a shit about her character and wasn't interested in her in anyway, which maybe her or it could be the writing? I'm not sure, but yeah this was a miss for me.
I think Bubble is extraordinary. Not number one, but definitely should be much higher up. I'm OK with everything else, but come on. Even the description makes it sound better than 14!
Agreed. I'm surprised how little credit it's generally given. I really enjoyed it, and the super-realism of the dialogue was necessary, to me, because any false sentiment would have wrecked the delicate, strange relationship between the main woman and her young male co-worker.
Then again, going through this list I was surprised at how much of Soderbergh's work I've really loved--I don't generally consider him a director I look out for. But I would knock down Erin Brockovich and Che, heavily. Brockovich was just a mediocre flick, and Che -- while it was definitely good, perhaps even great -- simply didn't earn its five-hour run-time. For a movie to be that much of an investment, it should have five hours' worth of things it wants to say, and Che really didn't.
"Traffic" should have gotten a Best Picture Oscar. "Out of Sight" was terrific. He's had quite a few misses, hasn't he? It doesn't surprise me that Sasha Gray ruined one of his films, she ruined "Entourage."
Yeah, she was the problem with "Entourage."
Personally, I've always thought Soderbergh was overrated. He essentially makes two kinds of movies: mediocre "indie" films and mediocre Hollywood films. Can we divide this list into "Sex, Lies, & Videotape" and "everything else"?
Agree with the write-up on Che. I feel a lot of critics misunderstood what he was trying to do with that film. I'd put Ocean's 11 on my top 5, but otherwise the list is pretty solid.
I'm so glad that Schizopolis made the top five. It almost forgives the sin of putting Solaris at the bottom (and I would be the first to concur that Tarkovsky's is better).
Solaris put my extremities to sleep. Pretty impressive for a movie.
Erin Brockovich is the best movie OF ALL TIME!!!!!!
UMMMMM definitely not, Julie Roberts is the worst!
Erin Brockovich. I saw this movie in 1998. It was called A Civil Action. The only difference is Julia Roberts' tits were Oscar worthy while John Travolta's weren't.
Solaris is definitely a better flick than it gets credit for here-- people just love to pile on george clooney. Of course the Tarkovsky version is better "cinema" but it's really impressive how Soderbergh manages to hit all of the same notes that Tarkovsky does in half the runtime, without feeling rushed.
I never really realized until looking at this list that Soderbergh casts women brilliantly, often getting a fairly limited actress (Natascha McElhone, Andie Macdowell, Julia Roberts over and over, Sasha Grey) into a role that is perfect for her. I think he could do very well with someone like January Jones.
ive never heard anyone regard Traffic as being anything but generic theater filler.
@mp: you're on crack if you think Traffic and something like Transformers 3 or any of the re-make/sequels in the theater are in the same category. But I bet you and your friends liked The Smurfs, right?
Actually mp's right, it basically blows. Generic moralizing drug story made artistic by film school 101 filter play. I expect Contagion to be Traffic if Traffic didn't suck.
Wow, I'd have put 'Erin' and 'Traffic' a lot lower on the list and 'The Limey' at #1. And 'Bubble' really needs to be higher.
Also; 'The Limey' has the hands-down greatest commentary track in the history of DVD bonus features.
@greg: totally agree about the commentary track.
Anyone know if theres going to be another Oceans movie??
I heard he's retiring after three more movies, so probably not.
Love the oceans movies
me too, oceans 11 is the perfect movie
Why u guys gotta hate on Traffic?!?! I LOVE TRAFFIC!!!
The limey is underated and sediment it makes me giggle
ok, so you are completely spot on with King of the Hill and the Secret Life of Alex Mack music....is it not the same exact song even???
wishing you'd chosen a picture of james spader, nerve!
You are way off on King of the Hill which should probably be#2 with Che at#1.Have you ever read the memoir it was based on?
The memoir isn't the movie.
good point
So much of what's 'good' about his films is derivative, and this list really highlights that. Traffic was copied from a british tv series in the late 80s, for instance
I want to throw in some more love for The Limey, which should be higher on this list--I'm really not sure why people tend to call it "light." Plus, King of the Hill is underrated--just check out the scene when the kids play marbles. I'm not kidding.
I have a much higher opinion of "King of the Hill" than this list does
I'd for sure put King of the Hill higher, maybe #3 though after Traffic and Che
definitely all good movies to watch (except I haven't seen 4 of these). Soderbergh provides a very entertaining and an a great film experience. He has a knack for incorporating political tension while at the same time leaving any bullshit opinion aside so as not to distract or offend the viewer. Shame to hear he'll be out of the game soon.
@DMV agreed. the memoir is very moving and highly recommended
Soderbergh himself claims he isn't retiring.
why George Clooney is in so many of his movies??
'Cause George Clooney is a shit actor
Excuse me?!?!?
The Limey is one of my all time favorite movies. Also really like Solaris and Sex, Lies, and Videotape. Ocean's were amusing. The rest...
I'm surprised no one has said anything about Spalding Gray. The guy totally changed my perspective on the one-act performance.
Spalding Gray is a shit actor.
Happy now?
I like Oceans 11 rocks my socks!
And the Green bay Packers sucked your cock.
Jim, you made my day.
..and you know, there is something very important we need to do as soon as possible..
F*ck.
I had a pseudo-argument with my boyfriend after reading this article about Solaris. I think its a beautiful film but wish they had done more with it. My boyfriend likes it, but can't tell me why exactly. I think its just one of those movies where you either like it or you don't. Now Kafka on the other hand...
Kafka was terrible.
I recall liking it quite a lot in its theatrical run but I was never able to track down a copy on LaserDisc and AFAIK it's not been issued on DVD or Blu-Ray Stateside. I hope it's somewhere between "as good as I remember" and "not half as bad as everyone else says it is."
'Solaris' is okay, I guess, but kind of a pointless remake. Overall, I prefer to just watch Tarkovsky's original, but I will admit I much prefer Soderbergh's ending.
About Traffic:
Although it's clear that this film presented a somewhat more complex vision on the war on drugs to the mainstream audiences --and that's laudable--, as a Mexican and a cinephile I can assure you that the film's approach falls short. Also, I always have found the stylistic choice of portraying the Mexican segments of the movie in a dusty sepia far from innovative.
The films in the top 10 are all good, and because of that I think they are all somewhat interchangeable. The reviewer seems to take awards into consideration, but I don't think you can really compare a movie like Schizopolis with Out of Sight, or either of those films with Erin Brockovich. They are good for their own reasons. I haven't seen King of the Hill, but I'm curious after reading this.
Traffic was a terrible joke of a movie. The plot was a warmed-over rehash of a 'Miami Vice' episode, the characters were cliche, the story was boring and predictable, and the big twist at the end was so ridiculously implausible that I threw up in my mouth watching it.
Erin Brokovich may be the largest misstep on this list. Julia Roberts is one of the most overrated actresses of all-time (up there with Sandra Bullock...or down there, if you will). I figure all the Oscar love pushed it up the list, but come on, Monique has an Academy Award.
Agreed about Julia Roberts. But why you gotta hate on Monique!?
Monique is a shit actor.
Anyone see Contagion yet?
Saw it last night. One of his best.
Best one of his I've seen in awhile, at least.
It's okay. Scientifically compelling, but overwritten and too moralistic. Dialogue is also uniformly terrible. I'm beginning to think Soderbergh's films are only as good as their scripts. His direction is actually pretty damn consistent, but the story aspect is where his films suffer.
Lyke that word "moralistic," huh, Mike?
I didn't realize this, but he really likes working with George Clooney. Like Scorcese loves working with De Niro and DiCaprio.
silverfox!!
and julia roberts
I think he has good stories and bad stories, i can see how sometimes its a little loose
KAFKA rules!
Solaris is my favorite one, I like it better than the original. It is so captivating and sensual, I love everything about it, I felt hypnotized while watching it, I have never been that much into a movie.
The only films I recognize are the A-list actor films and I never watched any of those. I do not apply to this list, but the fact that I do not have interest in any of his films puts them all at last for me.