FICTION




Good by Cheryl Strayed





In the end, my mother still knew a few things. She knew, for example, that telephones existed; that they had been a part of the world that she had been a part of. She yelled, "Answer the phone! Please stop the phone from ringing!" and then she sobbed and sobbed and asked why I was torturing her until she coughed and lost her breath and then gasped madly for it. (The phone was not ringing, but I put it in a drawer anyway.) She knew what an enchilada was. She demanded that one be gotten for her and heated up in the imaginary oven near her hospital bed. Given this, it would not be too much to suppose that she was aware of Mexican cuisine altogether. Likewise the existence of Mexico. Of Mexican people. Of people, though she did not, in the end, acknowledge them. She knew about cats and dogs and horses and believed them to be in the room with her. She hollered, "Don't sit on the bed or you'll squish Mister Carpaccio!" She knew that there was rain, especially raindrops. She sang a song that featured them and waved her fingers to the melody. On the very last day she panted, "What! What!"


    

"What? What?" I asked, begged.


    

"Oh," my mother said and moaned. She swung her head mournfully in my direction. She opened her eyes: blue, beloved, uncomprehending as a buzzard. "Now there you go again," she said. "Always interrupting me."


    

Before this, a couple of weeks before this, when she'd first been admitted to the hospital, she knew everything. She said, "For heaven's sake, open the curtains." She declared, "I'm not using any damn bedpan. I don't care. I'll die first! I still have my dignity, you know." How little she knew.


    

I sat and watched her for hours, days. I stroked the top of her head. Her hair — she had hair — was sharp and dry like the weeds that grow flat along the cracks in rocks.


    

"Oh," she moaned. "Don't touch me. It hurts. Everything hurts. You wouldn't believe the pain." She closed her eyes. "Let's sit and not say anything. That's what I want more than anything. Let's just be together and rest." I was twenty-one; my mother, forty. It was cancer, but not the way we'd imagined it would be.


    

Everything went very quickly, but it took a dreadfully long time.




There was a place called the Family Room where I went when I needed a break. There was a rainbow painted on the wall with a pot of gold at the end of it and a dancing elf doing a jig. Also, an itchy orange couch, a refrigerator, a microwave oven, a coffee pot and a water dispenser with one spout that was hot, the other cold.


    

I went to the Family Room and drank tea from a pointed paper cup and read the bulletin board.
There were signs advertising groups for people with AIDS, with chronic fatigue; for parents of premature babies or twins; for drug addicts and anorexics.


    

I stood and read those signs each day as if I'd never read them before. I stood perfectly still and erect and I was acutely aware of my stillness, erectness. Grief had suddenly, inexplicably, improved my posture. It had also, more understandably, made me thin. These things combined to give me the sensation that I had become an inanimate object. Something brittle, like the branch of a tree, or a broomstick.


    

Usually I had the place all to myself. One day a man walked in.


    

"Hello," he said. "I'm Bill Ristow."


    

"I'm Claire. Claire Wood." I shook his hand and held onto my empty paper cup. It was pliant and soft and wet as the petal of a lily.


    

Bill's eyes were hazel, sunken. He scratched his head with a pinkie finger. "My wife's in six-ninety. She's got cancer," he said. "Are you new here?"


    

"Kind of," I said. "My mom, she's been here a week. We didn't know anything. She had this bad cold and then all of a sudden it was cancer everywhere." I looked up at him, smiled, stopped smiling, went on. "Like three weeks ago they found it. And now the doctors say there's nothing they can do." I stared at the absurd green bumpers on the toes of my tennis shoes. I didn't know what I would or would not say. I didn't feel like I would cry. I had no control over either.


    

"Christ," he said and jingled the coins in his pocket. He was making coffee. The water fell one drop at a time into the pot. "Well, kiddo," he said, "I hate to say it, but in a way you're lucky. It's no vacation to drag it on. Nance and I — we've been doing the cancer thing for six years."


    

He was older but not old — my mother's age. I thought he might have been a wrestler in high school; his body dense and wide, like a certain kind of boulder; his face too — primitive. He wasn't good-looking. He wasn't bad-looking. He took a mug that said WYOMING! from the cupboard and another one with a chain of vegetables holding hands and filled them both with coffee. He handed me WYOMING! without asking if I wanted it.


    

"You and me have a lot in common," he said.


    

I didn't say anything. I cradled the coffee in both of my hands. I didn't drink coffee. I didn't like coffee, but I held it anyway. With pleasure.




"I was thinking about the time that I locked myself in the bathroom," my mother said.


    

"What time?" I sat with my knees pulled tightly up to my chest in the wide bay of the windowsill in her hospital room.


    

"You remember the time."


    

"I don't remember any time."


    

"I was furious with you. You were about six. I don't remember what you did. Probably a combination of many small things." She paused, looked over at me. Her beauty, even then, was like a Chinese lantern hanging in an oak tree. "It was just after I'd finally left your father. Anyway. Nobody tells you how it will be. I was so furious that I wanted to hurt you, I mean do you physical harm. Well, I didn't really, and I wouldn't have, but right then and there I felt capable of it. They don't tell you that when you become a mother — and nobody talks about it — but everyone has their breaking point, even with children. Especially with children." She laughed softly. "So. I went and shut myself in the bathroom to calm down."


    

"That was probably good," I said passively.


    

"Oh, were you ever mad! Just seething. You couldn't bear that I wouldn't let you in. You hurled your body against the door with all your might. I thought you were going to hurt yourself. I thought you would break a bone. I had to come out so you wouldn't."


    

I hopped down from the window and went and stood at the foot of her bed and rubbed the tops of her feet. It was the only place I could get at freely, without the tangle of tubes and plastic bags of fluid and tall carts holding the machines that sat near her head. We were quiet then. My mother fell asleep and I watched her face for signs of relief, which did not come. She held an expression of permanent tension and I could not discern if this was a new thing, or if it had been there all along, masked by the ordinary light of real life. Her chin hung slack, making the flesh beneath it baggy, but her mouth was strangely alert, puckered, and faintly streaked with vomit. I thought of the commercials of starving African children, the flies gathering at the corners of their eyes, the kids too weak to swat them away. How unbearable it was to see that, more so than anything else, more than all the other things, which were so much worse.


    

I got a T-shirt from my mother's duffel bag, wet it with warm water and wiped her face.


    

"Thank you honey." She opened her eyes. In slow increments, she turned her head to face the window.



           

  

Commentarium (31 Comments)

Apr 26 01 - 7:39am
AW

Whoa. That's a loaded piece. I'm not sure how I feel about the dynamics - social, emotional, moral... This piece was certainly not about the sex.

Apr 28 01 - 6:44am
gfz

I loved this story.

I don't know why but I identify with much of it.

Take care.

Apr 29 01 - 4:19am
s.b.

I've never cried so hard reading anything...

Apr 29 01 - 5:31am
CVS

This story was well written and rang true. For someone who has lost a parent to Cancer, I can relate to the narrator's need for intimacy. Grief makes you do "crazy" things, as does loss. I loved the imagery used to describe Nancy - I'm referring to the plum metaphor. For the author: Keep writing. I'll definitely keep reading!

Apr 29 01 - 6:28am
kay

thank you, cheryl.

Apr 29 01 - 4:31pm
hal

so nice. i remember the hospital, and the people dying and my friend dying and life weaving through anyway. my friend's girl and i sat in the hallway while she cried for her grandpa. we all played with the kids in the sun outside, singing stupid songs and playing statue and tag. we had a party in his room the night before he died, some wine, a couple of joints, some singing.

catching people when they come into this world, holding them while they leave, caring for them while their here. fucking as healing.

thanks for the story.

Apr 29 01 - 4:34pm
hal

re: AW's comment, "this piece is definitely not about the sex..." how is it not? isn't life all one cloth, and fucking and dying and grieving and joy all one thread?

Apr 30 01 - 6:33pm

Beautifully written, very emotional and devoid of crass sentimentality. There's definitely something sexual about death, however slightly it may manifest itself. Perhaps it's simply the urge to procreate in the face of mortality. But whatever the psychological reasoning, the way in which the needs of the two main characters are portrayed - and their unconditional love for those short days they were together - is a lesson to us all. It shouldn't take a death to do, but it so often does. Thank you for the story.
Chu Nagara

May 02 01 - 2:24am
bean

What a beautifully crafted story. Coming from central Canada, images of Manitoba, Fargo, and Duluth rang that much more poignant. I lost a good friend to cancer three years ago. I got transfered before he passed away three months later. I empathise with the desire for intimacy, however I found the last (non-)sexual act somewhat out of synch with the situation, more a psychological musing rather than an actual act.

May 02 01 - 9:12pm
sean

I feel so quiet inside having read your story.
Grief is our milk.
put on Lou Reed's "Pale Blue Eyes".

uncarbon@hotmail.com

May 03 01 - 9:18am
pmh

This is a beautiful story...

May 03 01 - 9:55am
sd

That was a beautiful story. I'm at work & I'm all choked up.

I'm going to call my mother now & tell her I love her.

May 04 01 - 11:35pm
B.J.

What rare vision and heart Ms. Strayed possesses. Her brilliant short story Good is that rare piece of writing that addresses life's unspeakable hardness and beauty with both unflinching clarity and generoisty of spirit. I look forward to reading much more of her work.

May 10 01 - 2:46am
RT

Cheryl

I was surprised by your short story, Good. I enjoyed it! It had an emotional depth that conveyed honesty and the sexual components were integrated naturally within the story.

I do enjoy erotica that is set naturally within general contexts.

Thanks

May 14 01 - 3:08pm
nbs

A great short story. I can relate. Being a sexual person, I can see the same sort of thing happen to me. Looking forward to the next story.

May 15 01 - 5:30pm
TAD

"Good" is more than good. It's the best short story that I've read in a long time and it's the best story I've read in the entire history of Nerve magazine (and yes, I have read them all!!!). Thank you for this great story.

May 16 01 - 6:01pm
jm

Amazing. Wrenching. True. Keep writing the truth and shaming the devil, Cheryl.

May 19 01 - 5:31pm
C.S.

An excellent story. Just excellent.

May 21 01 - 10:21pm
AA

Such a sad story...My mom has just turned 66. I have to remember that she won't be around forever...

May 28 01 - 6:21pm
NG

Ab odd little story, about unusal circumstances. Very well done... Nothing like sex with middle aged men!!

Nick

Jun 03 01 - 1:36pm
C.K.

Touching,yet erotic.Great work like this is rare but welcome.Showing sex as a comforting,healing act rather than just a selfish pleasure.
More soon please. Choco

Jul 05 01 - 1:01pm
Q.S.

Obviously Ms. Sontag's nom de plume, Ms. Strayed unleashes her real metaphor of illness in "Good." Good. Call me (in the afterlife--your next step). Mr. Quintin Crisp Strayed.

Aug 10 01 - 1:56pm

two snaps up and a circle

Aug 10 01 - 2:02pm
LSD

Exelent and tender...Healing and full of the litte wierd little things that we do...Grab "mugs that say Wyoming!" and scrunch up our faces during the sexual act "as though we are concentrating on something very close or very far..."

"It meant something to him that we had the same drink..."

The whole story had a sort of hikou quality to it....Its truth tender, tiny and transient...An amazing work please write more PLEASE...I NEED IT

Sep 15 01 - 11:41pm
KLN

This is a marvelous story, so beautifully written, so deeply true, so incredibly wise. It's precisely what I needed to read at this dreadful time of loss for so many in our nation. Thank you Cheryl Strayed. Thank you Nerve magazine. This story changed my life.

Sep 16 01 - 9:50am
km

What's so amazing, touching, well-crafted and emotional about a story of a man being unfaithful to his wife on her deathbed?

Sep 16 01 - 8:43pm
bd

that was absolutely beautiful. wow.

Sep 19 01 - 1:14am
BET

With my emotions on my surface because of 9-11, I wondered if I would be at my mother's side when she dies - would I be at my wife's side when she dies? Tremulous.

Sep 25 01 - 1:33am
smp

What an amazingly human story. I'm familiar with the types of grief involved in watching a loved one slowly go, and this account made me want to laugh and cry about my own memories of it. I have to wonder if the author is writing autobiographically about parts (or all) of this, because if not, the empathy evident in her writing is nothing short of staggering. I was touched on many levels and wish I could more personally express my appreciation to the author for her insight and her candor. Some of the most beautiful things in life can make a person cry.........

Nov 10 01 - 9:46pm
BB

How intense! There's so much to be said for the healing power of sex. My boyfirend's dad passed away a few years ago, and he and his three sisters and all of their significant others went to stay with their mom. The night after the funeral, after everyone left and we finally went to bed, I remember that while he and I were trying to be quiet while having sex, I could tell that his sisters and their SO's were all doing the same thing. Even though we broke up over six months ago, he still swears that he had the best sex of his life that night. As for me, the best sex I've ever had was the night we broke up. My pain definitely intensified my pleasure.

Now you say something

Incorrect please try again
Enter the words above: Enter the numbers you hear: