The Journal

My sophomore year of high school, I started keeping a journal. By that summer, it was up to two-hundred pages or so, and I was about to turn sixteen. I didn’t have a job or much else to do that summer, so I spent a lot of time hanging out at the pool, where my secret crush, Lily, was a lifeguard. A lot of times there was no one else around, so I’d just sit with her trying not to gawk at her body in her red one-piece swimsuit and hoping that she wasn’t gawking at mine (pale, acne-stricken, somehow both scrawny and fleshy at once).

I’d had a bunch of crushes on random unavailable girls up to that point, but Lily was the first girl I liked and was actually friends with. She was extraordinarily good at making you feel special — sharing private jokes and intimacies and judgments — and every time I spent time alone with her, I came away giddy with a feeling of grown-up love. The shared moments I recorded in my journal, which made them seem even more important.

I was narcissistic enough to believe that no one who learned everything about me could fail to love me.

In retrospect, she must’ve needed to create that sense of intimacy as much as I needed to feel it. I think she needed to be adored, wanted the validation of having others reveal themselves to her in trust. (Which I’m making sound sinister and manipulative, but really, she was just a sixteen-year old too.) Anyway, that’s probably why she kept asking to see my journal, even though I doubt she had any conscious idea how much exposure she was really asking for.

I didn’t either, but I had enough adolescent narcissism to believe that no one who saw me in totality could fail to love me. The last time she asked, I trotted from the pool over to the high-school computer center, where I burned out an ink cartridge printing out all 200 pages in the tiniest font, then brought it back to her all but in a bow. I knew that towards the end, she'd discover my true, more-than-friendly feelings about her, and I eagerly awaited her response.

For weeks after that, as she read through, she’d call me to tell me about little things I’d written that made her laugh or cry. (Very heightened times, these.) Finally, I couldn't wait any more, and when she was hanging out at my house one day, I just pointed to the right page and made her read it. By that point I was quivering and having trouble talking. She looked, and said, slowly, "Oh... I didn't know," and then, looking apologetic, "...and now I have to leave." And after that, we weren't really friends anymore. — Jason Carp

Have you ever done something totally crazy in the aftermath of a breakup? Experienced temporary post-relationship insanity? Tell us about it! Submit your 300-500 word true story to submissions@nerve.com or click here for more information

Commentarium (28 Comments)

Feb 13 11 - 2:01am
JL

Best feature Nerve has done in a long, long time.

Feb 13 11 - 2:10am
Z

Agreed. Completely agreed. This was beautiful.

Feb 13 11 - 4:41am
notfromaroundhere

Agreed. Absolutely.

Feb 13 11 - 4:53am
CodeNameDuchess

Loved this. The Great Cookie Offering hit so close to home.

Feb 13 11 - 11:41pm
eo

nice. vintage Nerve....really liked this one

Feb 13 11 - 3:31am
Lawrence

Amazing.

Feb 13 11 - 5:27am
oh man

Weekend Getaway hit me right in the kisser. ALl of these were completely raw and really effectively written.

Feb 13 11 - 6:56am
agreed

love this article, i can relate to the cookie story.

Feb 13 11 - 12:27pm
katydidnt

So, so good, all of them.

Feb 13 11 - 2:07pm
Eman

This was very very well done.

Feb 13 11 - 4:21pm
lalaland

i was blown away. great job on each story. this feature reminded me of nerve from about ten years ago, when the site had big literary aspirations.

Feb 15 11 - 12:32pm
nobody's geek

Agreed.

Feb 13 11 - 4:30pm
nice

nerve's first story ever about a fraternity. of course, it's a gay one. still, classic. love it.

Feb 14 11 - 6:10pm
Freddy

I like the implication from the picture that it's Princeton.

Jul 10 12 - 5:20pm
andrea

except does Princeton have frats?

Feb 13 11 - 5:16pm
Elle

I too have made cookies in my unused kitchen for sexual encounters that I wanted to validate. (God knows why I would this, an urge far surpassing my feminism) Will never bake a cookie again.

Feb 13 11 - 6:49pm
lalaland

I second what anna Dremousis said. Or hell, bake cookies for yourself, bake for the elderly, or bake for some NYC firefighters. Just don't bake with expectations. Sometimes you have to learn the hard way how to "respect yourself enough" to leave people alone when that's what they want. I don't think that lesson takes anything away from the lovely gesture, though.

Feb 13 11 - 5:44pm
anna Dremousis

I predict Litsa will bake cookies when she falls in love again. Food is love. It takes love to generate the cookie baking gene.

Feb 13 11 - 9:53pm
FeeGreen

Dear god that was the best thing I've read here in a long, long time. Great writers, great subject, and a relief from all the saccharine sweet v-day crap all over the place.

Feb 14 11 - 9:33am
im that guy.... :(

Beautiful story. I'm not looking for relationships, and people I get involved with know this - I have a lot of those amazing wurl wind not date dates that last all weekend with people I genuinely have feelings for - that said, still not ready to be someones serious someone. I hope I'n not hurting people :( xoxoxoxoxo.

Feb 14 11 - 11:41am
Wow

Awesome feature.

I too made the mistake of letter a girl read a journal that was made up almost exclusively of my pining for her as she broke up and got back together with me several times.

Extremely bad move. I feel sick even thinking about it. But she insisted once she discovered it existed.

Feb 14 11 - 12:18pm
Spitzy

Any story that begins with "I baked chocolate chip cookies for a guy I’d recently started sleeping with" and ends with "I don’t mind swallowing" is almost guaranteed to be one of the greatest things ever written.

Feb 14 11 - 1:15pm
MDM

Been there, done that. Why do we think our long dormant baking genes will get us anything but frustration? Off to bake for a more appreciative contingent - who subscribe to the notion "burned cookies are better than no cookies." LOVE that you share all the subtle nuances of loves, lost, found and in between.

Feb 14 11 - 6:26pm
MW

The Amelie girl was amazing and perfect. Nice to know there are women like that out there.

Feb 15 11 - 12:45am
Reinelle Apodaca

I baked these INCREDIBLE Martha Stewart Lime sugar cookie concoctions and mailed them to Seattle... Later, I was informed I had too many "things". I'm a girl!!! and "things" are just that. I don't need them. People are more important to me, which is why I baked the cookies in the first place!!! Sheesh! A friend of mine who knew him said that in another lifetime he was a servant of mine and would never feel like he deserved me! Freaky!!! Someday someone will appreciate my Martha Stewart cookies (I sometimes do giant bears with individualized sweaters)....Someday.

Feb 15 11 - 6:13pm
FR

This was so incredible, best valentines day cure ever!

Feb 17 11 - 5:26am
SH

My favourite is definitely the Weekend Getaway.

Bittersweet, sad, poignant and yet, is the only story of the series where there is a sliver of hope at the ending that things might work out.

Great set of stories.

Apr 13 11 - 4:10pm
Kassie

Stands back from the keyboard in amazement! Tahnks!