…even if you don't think you like mumblecore.
Mark Duplass doesn't classify the films he's co-directed with his brother (including this week's Jeff, Who Lives At Home and The Do-Deca-Pentathlon, which premiered at the SXSW Film Festival on March 11) as "mumblecore."
"It was just a tag that somebody started calling our movies," he explains — and by our, he means not just Duplass Brothers movies, but the work of a new generation of independent filmmakers, including Andrew Bujalski (Beeswax), Lynn Shelton (Humpday), and Joe Swanberg (Hannah Takes The Stairs). "I don't have a problem with people using tags in the press to help group things," Duplass clarifies, though he finds the term mumblecore "a bit reductive. But more importantly, it sounds hoity-toity and exclusionary… I want to invite everybody to see my movies." In that spirit, here are five reasons to see Jeff, Who Lives At Home, even if "mumblecore" sounds silly to you.
1. "Mumblecore" is pretty much just a synonym for "independent."
Duplass traces mumblecore back to Dogme 95, the manifesto concocted by Danish filmmakers Lars Von Trier (Breaking the Waves, Melancholia) and Thomas Vinterburg (The Celebration). That cinematic "vow of chastity" was an attempt to counter the cultural dominance of CGI-drenched mainstream fare with a lo-fi aesthetic emphasizing a more naturalistic vision of how actual humans interact and behave. Yet while digital technology has enabled mumblecore filmmakers to embrace the Dogme model, it's really just the latest incarnation of an observational, fly-on-the-wall style influenced by everything from Italian Neorealism to the work of American independents like John Cassavetes and Robert Altman. That vision unifies the mumblecore directors, whether their productions are low-budget festival bait or major studio releases like Jeff, Who Lives At Home.
2. It's nice to get a break from stories based on toys and robots.
Very few of us encounter vampires, hostile extraterrestrials, or serial killers in our day-to-day lives. But you wouldn't know it from the endless stories about them on TV and movie screens. In contrast, mumblecore's focus on believable characters and relationships often yields relatably funny and poignant moments that big-budget blockbusters can't match. Jeff hinges on the familiar yet complicated family dynamics fueling sibling rivalry, midlife crisis, and marital discontent. But it still provides enough comedy to make even the most painful moments go down easy.
3. The cast is great.
On the other hand, it's not like Hollywood completely shies away from solid relationship-based stories. Duplass is quick to note there's plenty of good mainstream filmmaking out there, and he's doing his best to contribute more, aided by stars eager to dive deep into nuanced, three-dimensional characters. In Jeff's fractious family unit, Jason Segel plays a realistically fleshed-out version of that familiar comedy staple, the slacker manchild, while Ed Helms is more sympathetic than antagonistic in the role of his alpha (minus) brother. Meanwhile, bucking the trend of older actresses only finding good roles on television, Susan Sarandon shines as the film's patient but frustrated matriarch, while Judy Greer follows up her work in The Descendants with another fine turn as a wife in a marriage drifting perilously close to the rocks.
4. The pace is relaxing, not exhausting.
One of the knocks against "mumblecore" is that the pace can seem meandering to viewers weened on rat-a-tat sitcom dialogue, machine-tooled three-act formulas, and rapid-fire editing. And while it's true that films by directors like the Duplass brothers often feature offbeat rhythms and plot twists (like The Do-Deca-Pentathlon's secret twenty-five-event competition between brothers over the course of a family reunion), the material likewise doesn't pummel viewers with meaningless sensation or beat them over the head with cynical deus ex machinas.
5. Mumblecore is sexy.
Finally, if none of the arguments above inspire you to check out Jeff or mumblecore in general, it's worth noting that the naturalism and emotional nakedness associated with the sub-genre often carries over to depictions of physical nakedness as well. Moreover, the sex in mumblecore films often feels a lot more authentic, intimate, and, well, sexy, than the mechanical coupling you see in Hollywood films. So dive in, take chances, and don't fear the "M" word.
Want to meet a Jason Segel type who doesn't live at home? Check out Nerve Dating.