Seven Lady Mensches I'd Like to Schtup

In honor of the High Holidays, the choicest of the chosen people.

By Ray Rahman

Yesterday, a Nerve writer brought you this list of the seven sexiest mensches she'd like to schtup. But, while often thought of as a male descriptor, the Yiddish term "mensch" can apply to either gender. And so, in honor of Friday's Yom Kippur, here are the upstanding Jewish women I'd bring home to Bubbe.

Natalie Portman

Natalie Portman

Natalie Portman is a lady mensch for every man. Along with her busy acting career, which has been thriving since she was a teenager, she's managed to go to Harvard, publish several academic papers, and become an outspoken activist -- for everything from Zionism to microfinance to vegan footwear. Whether or not you agree with her causes, you can't deny that she's as smart as she is passionate. And, of course, that she's sexy as hell.

Alison Brie

Alison Brie

This Mad Mensch started out acting in Jewish Community Centers, long before she took her beauty to television shows like, well, Community. She’s cute enough to have worked as a clown at birthday parties, but also hot enough to brag about the sexual misadventures of her youth on Nerve. (Said story, about trying to help a closeted gay friend lose his virginity, also makes a strong argument for her generous spirit.)

Jenny Lewis

For more than ten years, songstress/actress/Jewess Jenny Lewis released sweet lullabies with her band, Rilo Kiley, and lately has been working on her own solo material. Lewis is also the perfect lady mensch, both seductive and down-to-earth: “I like watching you undress,” she coos on Rabbit Fur Coat’s “Happy,” before adding “And, I think we’re at our best by the flicker of the light of the TV set.”

Rashida Jones

Rashida Jones

A literal mix of the suave Quincy Jones and The Mod Squad’s Peggy Lipton, Rashida Jones is obviously extremely cool. She sang TuPac poetry, played David Foster Wallace characters, and sexed up two of NBC’s finest sitcoms. Yet she still finds time to be one of the world’s sexiest philanthropists, giving her time and money to Housing Works, St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital, and the ONE Campaign.

Elizabeth Banks

Elizabeth Banks

The unrepentantly blond Banks is not only beautiful but also hilarious, as her turns in Wet Hot American Summer -- a Jewcentric send-up of ‘80s summer camp movies -- and 30 Rock have proven. A former shiksa, she met the menschy Max Handelman on her first day of college and joined the tribe upon marrying him.

Emmy Rossum

Emmy Rossum

Emmanuelle Rossum might be the most glamorous mensch on this list: she sang opera for the Met at the age of seven, she once played Audrey Hepburn, and she can claim Vera Wang as her aunt. She's nearly as accomplished a do-gooder: her efforts have advanced breast cancer awareness, AIDs prevention, environmental conservation, gay rights, and, of course, her own sexiness.

Maggie Gyllenhaal

Maggie Gyllenhaal

Maggie Gyllenhaal’s striking beauty is matched by her lightning-rod activism. She spoke out against the impending Iraq War at the Independent Spirit Awards in 2002, well before it was fashionable to do so, and she’s a longtime supporter of Witness, a non-profit that uses video to expose human rights violations. Of course, my favorite part of her career is Secretary, a film in which Gyllenhaal exposes something else entirely.

Commentarium (41 Comments)

Sep 15 10 - 7:27am
mrow

Maggie Gyllenhaal, really?

Sep 15 10 - 8:36am
Photo gal

Yes, really.

Sep 15 10 - 8:43am
Matt

Hooray Maggie.

Sep 15 10 - 8:50am
Jake A

Rashida Jones and Elizabeth Banks are really good choices.

Sep 15 10 - 8:51am
Sudsy

I want more on Jenny Lewis's menschiness.

Sep 15 10 - 9:34am
@Sudsy

Well, she once helped a sad little kid find a Warp Whistle in Super Mario Bros. 3. Gotta count for something.

Sep 15 10 - 9:42am
volumeknob

I had no idea half these gals were Jewish. Nice list!

Sep 15 10 - 10:37am
FT

Too bad Emmy Rossum doesn't have any actual talent to go along with those looks. She's been beyond awful in everything I've ever seen her in.

Sep 15 10 - 11:02am
jj

What about Emanuelle Chiquiri? The hottest Jewess on TV right now?

Sep 15 10 - 12:42pm
Nervesystem

Second that, jj

Sep 15 10 - 12:45pm
Sunbury

Look, I know Sarah Silverman would be a non-hip answer here. But.

Sep 15 10 - 1:32pm
@Sunbury

Sarah Silverman is no mensch.

Sep 15 10 - 6:25pm
PeteAK

Secretary was an AWESOME movie....kinda makes you say.....Sadomasochists are real people too....

Sep 15 10 - 9:29pm
Amber Lamps

I'd break my dick off in Rashida. Seriously.

Sep 15 10 - 9:51pm
noodlez

@Amber Lamps: Is that the douchebag version of circumcision?

Sep 15 10 - 10:39pm
mb

@mrow - Have you _seen_ Secretary?

Sep 15 10 - 10:58pm
sorry_correction

Jewish lineage is passed down matrilinearly. Banks doesnt count. Still as shiksa as my goyim ass. You guys/gals are allegedly smarter than this. Dumb column in many aspects.

Feb 27 11 - 11:31pm
Guest

You can convert to Judaism. It is true that there is an ethnic element to it, but I imagine that the rest of the list is quite a bit more closely related to Banks' people than to their own desert-dwelling forebears.

Sep 16 10 - 12:08am
Keith

My mom upon seeing The Dark Knight: "Why did they cast an ugly girl?"

Sep 16 10 - 1:12am
@sorrycorrection

Wow, way to offend the thousands of converted (like Banks) and patrilineal Jews that are accepted by Reform Judaism, which is by far the largest denomination in America. Prick.

Sep 16 10 - 5:44am
LC

The last one is a joke ?

Sep 16 10 - 7:12am
Maggie G

Is not cute at all, she looks like a mastiff or bassett hound.

Sep 16 10 - 7:58am
I shriek, you shriek

...we all shriek for Emanuelle Chriqui

Sep 16 10 - 9:18am
Curtis Lower

Maggie Gyllenhaal? What the hell were you thinking? She looks like Droopy Dog.

Sep 16 10 - 9:21am
Jo Dean

I think Elizabeth Banks is HOT.

www.privacy-web.cz.tc

Sep 16 10 - 9:29am
Goy

Yawn !

Sep 16 10 - 9:47am
John

Too bad their jewish...

Sep 16 10 - 9:55am
garm

Maggie Gyllenhaal? - nah

Sep 16 10 - 1:32pm
jd

Wow, this list is so fail. Maggie?...your a nut job buddy. No Bar Rafaeli? No Mila Kunis? No Brooke Burke? but MAGGIE??? You Sir, are FAIL.

Sep 16 10 - 1:41pm
Lizzy Caplan

belong on this list.

Sep 16 10 - 3:01pm
Jew Lover

Which one would Hitler do?

Sep 16 10 - 3:03pm
lucid doubletake

Any male author who would leave Sara Silverman off of a to-do list like this must be simply POSING as a straight guy. Ha ha, you had me goin there right up until I landed on Maggie Gyllenhaal. Which by the way, and for the record, is like stepping on an Asian land mine while walking to your own bathroom. In your own house. On a trail you have known to be safe from Asian land mines for as long as you have owned the place.
Seriously. Two things: Family commenters here should really read more into these selections. There is much more going on here than is obvious at the surface. Secondly, Sara call me! I'll show you a real list ;)

Sep 16 10 - 6:39pm
silverman

It's SaraH Silverman. With an H. And she might be hot and funny but she's not very menschy.

And Maggie Gyllenhaal is a babe:

http://topnews.in/usa/files/Maggie-Gyllenhaal.jpg

Sep 16 10 - 7:17pm
What?????

Have you guys seen maggie gyllenhaal in 1080p She's the reason I can't watch Dark Knight in HD.

Sep 17 10 - 2:23am
I love you Alison

Lizzy Kaplan no doubt should be on the list. Regina Spektor as well. Natalie Portman is a bit overdone these days. Sure she's gorgeous but come on get a little creative. Alison Brie by gets my vote for Jewess of the year. She truly is Hashem's gift to man.

Sep 17 10 - 6:28am
wakka

alona tal...

Sep 19 10 - 3:57pm
WW

I would take Mila Kunis over all of these women any day of the week!

Sep 20 10 - 4:05pm
Jeremy

Any list that doesn't include Kat Dennings = fail.

Sep 21 10 - 4:26pm
c'mon

what about Ginnifir Goodwin? How could you guys miss her? Stunning and actually was raised jewish (involved in JCC/had a bat mitzvah) I would say this is more a lady mensch than, say, Elizabeth Banks, who is a convert

Sep 24 10 - 4:36am
Glenn

Actually, 'Mensch' is a German term, but since Yiddish is a German dialect, I'll let it pass... :D

Nov 18 10 - 2:52pm
Damn...

This article brought out the most idiotic comments per word of any Nerve article. Congratulations, morons.