5. Fleet Foxes,  Helplessness Blues 

I don't think I've listened to any other album in the mornings this year as much as Helplessness Blues. "The Cascades" is the most soothing song to rub the sleep out of my eyes and browse the morning headlines to. Helplessness Blues has a tormented backstory: in 2009, the band spent $60,000 recording songs they ended up scrapping. Frontman Robin Pecknold's girlfriend of five years broke up with him because of the stress the album put on their relationship. He then jumped into a number of side projects to give him a break from the the album. He was sure that it would come out by 2010; it was released in February of 2011. There’s something trite here about pressure and coal and diamonds, but I’ll spare you  just listen to the album.  — Maura Hehir 

Listen: “Helplessness Blues”

 

4. Tom Waits, Bad As Me

Waits delivered a career summary with Bad As Me: it’s everything you’ve loved about his past work, delivered in a voice that’s never felt stronger, with concise songwriting and production. Familiar collaborators Marc Ribot and Keith Richards return, giving Bad As Me a family reunion-type feel. The songs are still by turns tender and odd, but Waits’ old-man indignance on “Hell Broke Luce” shows that he’s not yet done chronicling the downtrodden he’s just summoned a righteous anger to match his always-affecting sentimentality. — A.H.

Listen: “Hell Broke Luce”

 

3. tUne-yArDs, w h o k i l l 

w h o k i l l marks Merrill Garbus’ transition from a one-woman DIY project to a fully-fledged band, and the group's first studio release is riotous, colorful, and bold. Every song is a journey through Garbus’ expansive musical vocabulary  the album gleefully blends disparate fragments like the drum patterns of dub and the chanted vocals of Afrobeat. On "Killa," Garbus bleats, "I'm a new kind of woman." If that's true, I hope there’s a whole army of new women following in tUnE-yArDs' footsteps, because the world needs more music like this. — C.M.

Listen: “Killa”

 

2. PJ Harvey, Let England Shake

PJ Harvey’s superbly crafted Let England Shake, the concept album that won her the coveted Mercury Prize in 2011, deals largely with World War I. But Harvey’s visceral lyrics keep the album from veering into lecturing shrillness, and the soft, autoharp-infused accompaniments bump up nicely against the rawness of the subject matter. The battlefield imagery is disturbing at times: soldiers fall "like lumps of meat," and trees are hung with severed limbs in "The Words That Maketh Murder."  Her conflicted feelings towards England inform every song: “You leave a taste,” she informs her homeland in “England”  “a bitter one.” For an unusually gripping and even-handed concept album dealing with a lofty and often broadly-painted subject, Let England Shake is nothing short of a triumph. — M. C.

Listen: “Let England Shake”

 

1. Adele, 21 

When “Rolling in the Deep” hit every radio station in existence simultaneously over the summer, it was labeled a “crossover hit,” a definition that seems redundant — nothing translates across musical spectrums like a broken heart. Getting dumped is the fucking worst.  And God strike down whoever says “everything’s gonna be all right.” When you’re in the throes of heartache, advice falls on deaf ears. And throughout 21, Adele isn’t offering any. Instead she’s a vessel, giving you the chance to belt out what you’ve been feeling all this time but couldn’t put words to. She holds your hand, and strokes your neck, and waits. She knows you may not come out of this unscathed — none of us do — but that, eventually, you will come out of it. — Rick Paulas

Listen: “Someone Like You”

 

Runners-Up:  Florence + The Machine, Ceremonials; The Black Lips,  Arabia Mountain; Fucked Up, David Comes to Life; The Roots, Undun; Wilco, The Whole Love; The Black Keys, El Camino; Battles, Gloss Drop; Gilian Welch, The Harrow & the Harvest; Liturgy, Aesthetica

Commentarium (60 Comments)

Dec 15 11 - 3:05am
Mikhail

No love for the rich, career-topping new Feist album? "Metals" is resoundingly my favorite of the year. And I love "21."

Dec 15 11 - 10:18pm
dani02q

ok

Dec 15 11 - 3:27am
JDC

Love Future Crimes by Wild Flag. Very 90s Seattle.

Apr 25 12 - 10:15pm
LED Panel

LED Grille is a lighting,led corn light, suitable for installation in the ceiling of the Scriptorium. The light source is usually a fluorescent tube. Divided into embedded and the ceiling. HEG Enterprises LED Grille imported organic board materials, luces online,transparency and good, even and soft light, fire performance, environmental compliance. The chassis made of high quality cold rolled sheet, surface phosphating spray Process, good corrosion resistance, easy to wear, faded. All plastic parts are made of flame retardant materials.
LED Grille As a result of the solid light source luminous, compra venta leds,life depends on the solid LED light source and driver cooling part of the LED source life has reached more than 100,000 hours, with the increasing popularity of LED technology continues to development and application of technology in drive and cooling has basically reached the ideal state, leds para iluminacion,a commercially available high-quality LED spotlight life is basic to 10000-50000 hours, almost 10-50 times the normal halogen spotlights. Power-saving LED lighting products up to 80%, almost maintenance-free, e40 bulb,does not exist the problem must be frequently changed parts, about six months down the cost savings in exchange for the cost. Semiconductor light source of the green type, light and soft, pure spectrum, vision care and physical health of workers. Pattern.

Dec 15 11 - 5:20am
DraperFan

You really should've used one of the live versions of "Someone Like You". They all shatter the album version to smithereens.

Dec 15 11 - 10:58am
blahblah

21 is ridiculously overrated. Just an okay pop album.

Dec 15 11 - 11:11pm
rich

how can you say it's overrated when it's not an over auto-tuned album?

Dec 16 11 - 9:34am
blahblah

Don't get me wrong, it's not a bad album, I guess the praise comes from the basic fact that it's shocking that a pop album isn't complete shit, so it's automatically "Greatest Album EVERRRR"

Dec 16 11 - 4:48pm
sweet!

Actually I think the reason it's so popular is because it expressed itself so succinctly . The lyrics are depth filled and they're put to catchy music. I wouldn't say it's overrated ...it's musical genius. Adele hit the mark on the head with this one-it appeals to everyone...pain is universal.

Dec 17 11 - 4:33pm
blahblah

There ARE a few great songs on that album, but as a whole? it's really not all that great. Rolling In The Deep, Someone Like You and Turning Tables are fanatstic, but let's not forget there are 9 more mediocre songs on that album, so the album itself, in my opinion does not deserve the "Best Album Of The Year" title. that is all.

Jan 22 12 - 3:37pm
lady boots

completely agree with blah. there are some really bad songs on there that are saved only by her incredible voice. the tune-yards album is by far the best of the year.

Dec 15 11 - 11:03am
Rutherford B. Hayes

I like this list. The Mountain Goats and Destroyer both put out fantastic albums this year, which I'd have included in the top 5---and I wasn't wild about the PJ Harvey record---but I can't argue with Adele at number one. I personally think an album of the year should break everyone's heart a little.

Dec 16 11 - 11:54am
thinkywritey

In talking to a friend who lightly knows the singer for the Mountain Goats, I said, "If I were sitting next to him, I'm not sure if I'd want to burst into tears or jump his bones." She said, "He'd be pleased with either of those reactions."

Dec 25 11 - 6:01pm
Bananas

The Mountain Goats! (Nerdfighter, anyone?)

Dec 15 11 - 11:18am
BobbyOrr

No Kaputt! I can objectively say, your list is wrong without Destroyer.

Dec 15 11 - 5:12pm
EdwardSF

I couldn't agree more!

Dec 15 11 - 11:32am
catherine

The 20 Unhappiest People You Meet In The Comments Sections Of Year-End Lists
http://www.npr.org/blogs/monkeysee/2011/12/14/143699630/the-20-unhappies...

Dec 15 11 - 11:45am
LAP

Well played. When I saw the title of the article, I immediately thought of this list.

Dec 15 11 - 7:49pm
...

+1

Dec 17 11 - 8:49pm
Lawrence

#1.

Dec 22 11 - 3:18pm
julian.

+1

Dec 15 11 - 11:49am
Crooklyn

Can I just say how badass it is that the top three artists are women, or does that defeat the badassness by calling attention to it? Are we post-feminism at this point?

Dec 17 11 - 7:00am
H-J

Congrats! You've just defeated the badassness.

Dec 19 11 - 1:53am
Little GH

agreed, badassness defeated.

Dec 15 11 - 1:47pm
MikeyFresh

Yerr Frank Ocean's sick

Dec 18 11 - 3:07am
Ryan

I came to this list hoping Nostalgia/Ultra would be on it... wasn't disappointed. By far the best album I've heard in a very long time.

Dec 22 11 - 3:18pm
julian.

Agreed.

Dec 15 11 - 1:47pm
MikeyFresh

Golf Wang

Dec 15 11 - 4:00pm
su

you had me until number 1 turned out to be Adele - now I can't meet you in the eye. I'd have gone for either ghostpoet or metronomy evening out the pack and shifting PJ Harvey up one to first.

Dec 15 11 - 5:40pm
Wait, what?

So ADELE is number one because of one song? I thought this was best ALBUM of the year not BEST recording. Way to go Paulus.

Dec 15 11 - 6:05pm
startmakingsense

"...And THROUGHOUT 21, Adele isn't offering any." as in, the whole album. also, you misspelled his name. idiot.

Dec 15 11 - 6:00pm
....

I love you Annie Clark!

Dec 15 11 - 6:09pm
Lawrence

=( Adele? Really? One hit wonders don't deserve best album awards. This list is so ridiculous you might as well have a 2010 album on here. High Violet. Yep. I said it. Best album this decade. What? Yep.

Dec 19 11 - 1:08am
Timmeka

Adele is not a one hit wonder...I agree that she should be number.

Dec 15 11 - 6:09pm
Lawrence

Oh, I don't mean the list is ridiculous, but putting Adele up there destroys credibility.

Dec 15 11 - 6:40pm
Els

Out of all the lists I've seen this year (and I've seen many) this was by far the best...until - Adele. No!!! Please, no! In other words, I agree with the other commentators without doubt. No Adele.

Destroyer's 'Kaputt' should have absolutely been in the top 10. Mountain Goats would have been nice but hey. And you guys (well, whoever put this list together) would surely love the War on Drugs album, no?

Fantastic to see Frank Ocean here though!

Dec 15 11 - 6:42pm
startmakingsense

i don't understand the knee-jerk reaction to 21. It's a good album. Pop music doesn't always have to mean bad music, and I would rather listen to her than that reedy-voiced Lit nerd from the Mountain Goats or Destroyer's homage to '80s pop.

Dec 16 11 - 6:45am
Els

Not knee-jerk. Thought about long and hard, mate.

Dec 15 11 - 7:42pm
...

Middle Brother. Thank you, please.

Dec 15 11 - 9:36pm
Alexander

Adele is number one, no question. I was amazed how many people I know, people who aren't even necessarily that into music, felt so passioante about 21. I mean, friends of mine who don't really listen to albums, as a whole, went out of their way to buy or download it, and listened to it nonstop for months, and, in discussing it, would express depths of feelingI hadn't, frankly, expected to encounter from them. They were really moved by 21. So was I. And I think when a work of art has this ability to create a cultural moment, it's significant. There was a lot of great music released in 2011, but Adele stands on her own.

Dec 16 11 - 2:53am
THIS

Yeah, I feel like a lot of the commenters against '21' are just trying to stay away from anything mainstream. There were some flaws on '21' but nothing so egregious as to say it doesn't belong on this list. "Someone Like You" near brought me to tears. "Turning Tables" the lyrics are just so good. I LOVE this album. And I love the effect it's had on the music market - a modern release that proves people still listen to albums and can digest more than a collection of singles.

Dec 16 11 - 2:33am
PP

No love for the Decemberists? King is Dead was wonderfully solid album.
(Or perhaps this is the misfortune of a January release date.)

Dec 16 11 - 8:59pm
D

No kidding, this album blows away half of the above lame ass albums!

Dec 16 11 - 8:44am
l

really good list, im making this my xmas list this year but adding the real estate and horrors album

Dec 16 11 - 10:54am
snees

Kurt Vile's "Baby's Arms" is so great.

Dec 16 11 - 11:09am
Alex Heigl

+1.

Dec 16 11 - 1:16pm
Johan

+2

The whole album is so good. Glad to see it on the list.

Dec 17 11 - 3:33am
Mikhail

Well, at least the New York Times got it right: Feist's "Metals" sits proudly as their choice for best album of the year.

Seriously: it blows away most everything on this list.

Dec 19 11 - 7:11pm
Karla

It also had Paul Simon at number 2 and Kayne-Z at number 3...

Dec 17 11 - 1:14pm
Michael Elgin

'The Black Kids' are an interesting indie-band.

Dec 20 11 - 4:08pm
mb

Circuital, My Morning Jacket - A great live band at a creative peak - while Evil Urges and Z are very good, this one is an instant classic.

Dec 22 11 - 3:18pm
julian.

This year was a pretty great year for music. Can't wait till next!

Jan 06 12 - 6:59pm
Kelly

no Future Islands??

Jan 09 12 - 11:14am
Alex Heigl

Personally, I don't think On the Water quite lived up to In Evening Air.

Jan 08 12 - 8:51am
Matt

Seriously? Come on, Bon Iver, no. 13? What is that? Okay, maybe not the best album of the year, but definitely in the top 3. It's inventive; the instrumentation is intricate and effective; and the lyrics of all the songs, are just amazing. The lyric "And at once I knew, I was not magnificent" is so brutally effective. There are so many other amazing albums that weren't even mentioned; although James Blake's self-titled album definitely deserved that spot. But "21" by Adele as number one? God, it's banal, her voice is good but there are a lot of better singers out there, and she's doing what so many artists have done before her. I'm not saying it's a bad album, it is a good album, but the album gets (musically) boring very quickly. Personally it's not even in my top 20.

Jan 09 12 - 10:21am
Lucifer

NO F'N METAL!!!!!!?

Jan 09 12 - 11:15am
Alex Heigl

Liturgy, my Dark Lord. Listen and love.

Jan 15 12 - 12:14am
snotbubble

not one of these made my best album list for 2011, but then again who cares about lists.

Feb 08 12 - 9:22am
tv on the radio

Numero uno

Jul 26 12 - 10:55pm
cemeteryheart

Compared to her debut album 19, Adele's 21 is weak...