Uh-oh — looks like the upcoming The Muppets, despite releasing a series of charming trailers and being written by self-admitted Muppets super-fan Jason Segel, is getting some flak from people who were involved in the much-beloved original films. The main concern seems to be that Segel doesn't have a firm grasp of the characters, and also that there are fart jokes:

The concern among Muppets insiders is that Segel and director James Bobin (a writer on Da Ali G Show and Flight of the Conchords) didn't have a complete understanding of the Muppets characters or were willing to sacrifice the characters' integrity to land a joke. "They're looking at the script on a joke-by-joke basis, rather than as a construction of character and story," says one.

A small example is in one of the many trailers Disney has released, when Fozzie makes a fart joke. "We wouldn't do that; it's too cheap," says another Muppets veteran. "It may not seem like much in this world of [Judd] Apatow humor, but the characters don't go to that place."

Also an issue: the Muppet gang have "broken up" at the start of the film, apparently because of bitterness over Kermit's new-found wealth. (It is hard to imagine the frog who so sweetly sang "Rainbow Connection" in a swamp living in a mansion, it's true.)

And these are not the only rumblings coming from people associated with the old-school Muppets. Frank Oz, the man who was the voice of Miss Piggy and also directed a Muppet movie himself, declined to participate in the new film after reading the script. Before saying he doesn't want to be a crank when it comes to the movie, he admitted that, "I don’t think they respected the characters." Purely out of my desire to see another good Muppet movie, I hope these people are wrong about Segel's project. But if you go to the multiplex and find that Kermit et al. have been Shrek-ified, don't say no one warned you.

Commentarium (11 Comments)

Oct 21 11 - 5:22pm
nerkums

They're not wrong.

Oct 21 11 - 7:26pm
<3

:( :( This literally makes me want to cry. The fart joke WAS concerning, but Jason Segel seems to love the Muppets so much! :( :( I thought they were safe in his hands! :(

Oct 21 11 - 10:02pm
Mr. Man

Sorry, but all post Jim Henson efforts are pointless capitalism. Which comes as expected but still feels like a violation.

Oct 21 11 - 10:40pm
djg

I just don't want anyone to mess with the Muppets. HANDS OFF! I'm looking at YOU, Hollywood. You will not improve them. Piiiiiiiiiiiiiiiigs Iiiiiiiiiiiin Spaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaace

Oct 21 11 - 10:46pm
djg

I just don't want anyone to mess with the Muppets. HANDS OFF! I'm looking at YOU, Hollywood. You will not improve them. Piiiiiiiiiiiiiiiigs Iiiiiiiiiiiin Spaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaace

Oct 22 11 - 12:43am
999

What did you think would happen when Disney bought the rights?

Oct 22 11 - 1:30am
NEIN NEIN NEIN !

Derp derp derp...

Oct 22 11 - 3:17pm
BrosephofArimathea

I'm glad I don't give a shit.

Nov 21 11 - 3:58am
Coralee

God help me, I put aside a whole afternoon to fiugre this out.

Jan 26 12 - 1:36am
Damascus

I actually kinda loved the new Muppets movie. I thought everyone was rather well handled and it felt good to see them back on the screen and not being whored out in some silly Wizard of Oz/Treasure Island/Muppets in Space kind of way. Those were all just movies that watered down the brand so much that Jason Segel had a long way to go to bring them back to their former glory. Whether you love the movie or not, it's not a bad film. It's getting my 4 year old into the Muppets, so for me, it totally achieved it's goal and then some.

Feb 09 12 - 11:04pm
Onthepayroll?

Ummm ok Mr. segel-
You do realize you could have introduced the child to the 20 DVD set of The Brilliant
Muppet Show- or Brilliant first 3 movies-
The brand was NOT watered down- As people who HAD talent worked on the projects-
The whole "Apatow" Trend is hopefully coming to an end-
If you are going to Rip off Mel Brooks EVERY time- Try to do it right.....
And before you say- look how much money they made-
The Muppet Movie's made more then Any Apatow film at 2.50 tickets- NOT 11.00 tickets.
Hack