Not a member? Sign up now
New York Philharmonic interrupted by ringing cell phone
By EJ DicksonJanuary 12th, 2012, 1:30 pmComments (11)
Concertgoers at Avery Fisher Hall were in for an unpleasant surprise last Tuesday evening, when in an almost unprecedented move, New York Philharmonic music director Alan Gilbert interrupted a performance for an audience member's ringing cell phone. According to the New York Times' ArtsBeat Blog, Gilbert stopped the orchestra during its performance of Mahler's Ninth Symphony to ask the unknown audience member to turn off the phone, which had been ringing ceaselessly throughout the movement.
The ringing started during what Gilbert said was the "most emotionally wrought part of Mahler Nine," a symphony that the Times says contains some of the "most spiritual and peaceful music ever written." When no one in the audience would 'fess up to being the owner of the offending mobile device, Gilbert sought out the location of the sound, while audience members screamed "Thousand-dollar fine!", "kick him out!" and "Get out!"
Eventually, a few audience members pointed out a couple in the front row where the sound was coming from. Gilbert politely asked the man to turn off his phone, then turned to the audience to apologize before launching into the final movement. "It was so shocking what happened," Gilbert said. "Usually you're in this faraway spiritual place in the piece. It was like being rudely awakened."
Although ringing cell phones are a common nuisance in concert halls, even during performances given by the world-renowned New York Philharmonic, Gilbert said this time the sound was too loud and persistent to ignore. But what I find most shocking about this story is not the rudeness of the offending audience member who didn't turn off his phone, but the viciousness of the jeers from the audience in reaction to the disruption; one blogger even said that they sounded like they were "out for blood."
Out for blood? Really? Because some douche who's probably never been to a concert other than Bonnaroo his sophomore year of college forgot to turn off his cell phone? I mean, granted, Mahler Nine at Avery Fisher Hall is not The Muppets at Loews Cineplex, but still, it sounds like these patrons-of-the-arts types would've pulled out their brass knuckles and rumbled, West Side Story-style.







Commentarium (11 Comments)
Those tickets aren't cheap and orchestra goers ought to know better. Blood is probably a bit harsh, but to let it ring like that? Fuck yes, throw him/her/them out!
Definitely. I mean, the dude should've hung up the second he felt his phone ring, and the fact that he didn't until after the conductor (!) told him to shut it off is pretty unbelievable. I just think the image of these straight-laced, tux-wearing audience members booing and jeering this schmuck like they're at Fenway Park instead of the New York Philharmonic is pretty funny :-)
Is it? People are pretty much the same where ever you go.
Charles Mingus used to cut his band off and allow talkative club patrons time to act as unwitting "soloists." Maybe that might have been a good alternative tactic.
Nobody needs to have a cell phone on at an event like this, for any reason. Asking people to behave isn't too much.
By the way, I still fail to see the point of "Captcha" words that are impossible to read.
The volume of spam comments (both automated and trolling-related) has dropped to an insanely low amount since we implemented the Captcha. That said, it is hard to read, and we're looking into alternatives, whether they be a new Captcha or making a Nerve account mandatory for leaving comments.
Yes, well, based on your quotes, nobody was out for blood, but they do have the right to be angry. People pay to hear the music, not this jackass' cell phone. What all of these a-holes need to learn is that they are simply not that important... shocking, I know. The human race existed centuries before having a phone on them all the time and despite it's addictive qualities, it can wait.
Having worked in classical venues for 20+ years I know that audience members are reminded to silence their phones in their programs, on their tickets, via curtain speeches, posters, etc. You have to be some kind of major d-bag to let your phone keep ringing. Management should have refunded their ticket price and asked them to leave.
I could see a phone ringing once. Everyone forgets to turn their darn things off. But repeatedly? Not acceptable, particularly in this context. Mahler 9 is already 75+ minutes; why make it longer by causing trouble?
They ask everyone to check their phones at the beginning of the evening. That means TAKE IT OUT AND MAKE SURE IT'S ON VIBRATE OR OFF. If you can't do this one simple thing then you deserve what you get. (Like when I hollar at ignoramt fucks in a movie theater.)
I was at a Joshua Bell concert one time where the woman in front of me opened a Velcro pocket about five minutes in. The noise of course carried all throughout the Kimmel Center (we were nowhere near the stage.) He stopped, waited a moment, said "please excuse me" and started over from the beginning.
Some bonaroo douche who's never heard classical music before? Come on. The idiot was in the front row, so chances are he was some old fart with upper-register hearing loss who couldn't hear the damn thing.
Solution: don't let old people have cell phones.