Wishful Drinking author Carrie Fisher, who you gotta love for her candor about her past LSD use and electro-shock therapy, is currently engaged in a light-hearted YouTube war-of-words with William Shatner over which is the superior franchise, Star Trek or Star Wars. Shatner started the AARP sci-fi beef back in September, saying in a YouTube interview that Star Trek had better storylines, while Star Wars was all special effects and derivative ideas.

In response, Fisher recently came back with her blaster blazing, saying:

"They're not in the same league. I mean, they have the word 'Star' in the title, and, um, there's space travel — right, where did they go to? I don't really... Klingon? It just sounds like a laundry detergent."

She also took a shot at Star Trek's budget, saying "Maybe they're just, they're effects, they're not called special effects." And responding to Shatner's having suggested that Industrial Light & Magic (ILM) and the costume department may have been hiding less-than-attractive Star Wars cast members, Fisher, referencing Princess Leia's metal bikini, said "I had the metal bikini. By the way, Bill has borrowed it." Fisher then suggested they have a costume-off, with her friend saying Leia's bikini vs. Captain Kirk's "sausage outfit." Fisher played up Star Wars' superior merchandising, saying her "space buns are so much better than Nimoy's ears." (I agree with her there.) And somehow, Sarah Palin and Dick Cheney's penis entered the conversation.

These hypothetical, "Who would win" parlor debates are fun, like Ali vs. Tyson, Superman vs. Batman, Debbie Gibson vs. Tiffany, etc. In the case of Star Trek vs. Star Wars, they are, of course, two totally different entities. The original Star Trek series had its share of Shakespeare-trained actors, but they didn't have ILM, though, ironically, later Star Trek movies would go on to use the services of George Lucas' visual-effects house. So the question of which franchise is better will never be answered, though litmus tests like one's preference between Jeri Ryan's Seven of Nine from Star Trek: Voyager and Fisher's Princess Leia and her Frederick's of Hollywood get-up will still retain their usefulness. Alas, the Peter Cushing-Nichelle Nichols feud that might have been.

 

Commentarium (5 Comments)

Nov 17 11 - 7:30pm
Wow

Is that really Carrie Fisher?

She looks HORRIBLE! Wasn't she just on 30 Rock two years ago? She looked great then!

Nov 17 11 - 8:29pm
Plastic Surgery Wars

It's remarkable. I (not being American/not owning a TV) never saw her on 30 Rock, but it's like it's not her at the same time it is. Bizarre.

Nov 17 11 - 10:01pm
Equidae

People age, plus I doubt she has a makeup crew on standby in case she does an interview in her backyard.

Nov 17 11 - 10:12pm
Equidae

I'm a star wars loyalist thru and thru, but even so I do think star trek is the better written and better executed story. Generally, trek has some serious turds to be sure. But the prequels... Had it not been the prequels, if george had had an a stroke right after the ewok live action movies were released, and the franchise just been allowed to pass gracefully instead of the decennial buggery and flogging of the originals star wars would have won.

Nov 21 11 - 3:05pm
GeeBee

Ali vs Tyson? Seriously? No contest. The short guy chases the tall guy for three rounds, gets seriously winded, then receives a lesson in how to jab until the referee steps in.