OPINIONS



        
I don't think Six Feet Under is the cat's ass. It's well-written, but the dramatic resolutions on Alan Ball's HBO funeral-home opus are a little too clean, a little too let's-everyone-hug gooey. The show's principal device — having dead people haunt/guide the living cast members — is theater-camp hokey. Plus, I'm instinctively prejudiced against any series that gives a role to Ed Begley Jr.


    

That said, the show is better than 95 percent of the junk on TV, and it has true innovative merits. The first is Rachel Griffiths, who plays Brenda Chenowith, the brilliant yet emotionally tortured girlfriend of Nate Fisher. The hardest thing to authenticate on screen is a brain — usually the solution is to put a pair of glasses on someone like, um, Sandra Bullock — and yet Griffiths manages to project a frayed intelligence that makes her both human and a bit unnerving. Everyone knows a Brenda. Some of us even broke up with a few.


    

But Six Feet Under's greatest contribution may be its portrayal of sex. That's not simply because the principal character, David Fisher (Michael C. Hall) is gay, wound tight as a top, and spent much of the first season trying to come out to family and friends. Nor is it because Six Feet Under is on HBO, and therefore can show a bit more T&A than, say, 7th Heaven. (Though it does show a breast or a penis now and again, or a naked stiff, Six Feet Under is actually somewhat restrained with the flesh, especially compared to the theatrics of Sex and the City, or the peepee-a-minute Oz.)


    

No, what makes Six Feet Under a breakthrough for sex and television is its staunch unwillingness to draw attention to the act itself. After years of watching television repeatedly push the boundaries of sex, sex talk and sexual depiction — to the point where the show practically bragged how in-your-face they were — it's pleasing that the sex on Six Feet Under is just matter-of-fact. That's not to say it's repressed, or ignored — it just exists. Whether it's David's dalliances in clubland, his sister Claire's teenage misadventures (which usually take place in the back of a hearse), or Nate and Brenda's flat-abbed, yogalike lovemaking, the show steadfastly seeks to depict sex as it is — an act between people, not something used to hype a television series upon, or to give jollies to chubby television critics.


    

And though the sex portrayed on Six Feet Under is hardly conventional for television — Ball's greatest barrier-breaker may be giving a sex life to Fisher matriarch Ruth (Frances Cornoy), now widowed in her late fifties — it's not freighted with the self-conscious, look-how-daring-we-are theatrics that pretty much take the fun out of sex on TV. Sexual breakthroughs on TV have usually been important but pretty boring, to tell the truth, whether it was Ellen, the two guys in bed on thirtysomething, the Big Lesbian Kiss on L.A. Law, or even Dylan getting into Brenda's pants after the prom on Beverly Hills 90210. Producers often are so proud of themselves for taking sexual risks that they fail to make the act interesting at all. Or they go so over the top, it becomes boring, too. Seriously, when was the last time you got excited after seeing Kim Cattrall get some action?


    

Six Feet Under also refuses to engage the oldest rule of sex in television, which states that for every misbegotten sexual adventure, there must come a big learning moment. You've seen it in everything from Friends to a Very Special Episode of Blossom — no good boink goes unpunished. Even Sex and the City's characters do some morning-after learning. Six Feet Under, however, doesn't feature much post-coital deliberation. That's not to say there isn't scattered reflection and regret — by the end of season one, for example, David had sworn off his booze and ecstasy-fueled one-nighter, and sought a return to monogamy — but there's never been the overarching finger-wag that usually accompanies TV sex. David ultimately realized his quick-pleasure sex life was making him feel empty. He wanted to fix it and find his old boyfriend. And you know, that's how real people usually do it.


    

There's other stuff — Claire's teenaged sex life is about as genuine a portrayal as you'll get, full of mistakes and contradictions, fits of insecurity and queasy pleas from unfit boys. The fact that she's having sex — and the writers don't use it to force some gigantic household meltdown — is remarkable unto itself. Mom Fisher has slept with two suitors already (and accidentally taken one of David's ecstasy tabs, which had been hidden in an aspirin bottle). Ironically, it's Nate and Brenda who lately seem to be doing it the least, but then again, that's not unusual in couples where the initial attraction was sex. They'll likely get back to it in due time. But at least on Six Feet Under, it won't merit a Very Special Episode.

©2002 Jason Gay and Nerve.com, Inc.

Commentarium (19 Comments)

Mar 13 02 - 12:22am
dk

Though writen with good intentions. This article has not been researched very well. David does get arrested in the first season after having sex in public with a male prostitute in las vegas. He is subsiquently repremanded by his ex who shows up to bail him out.

Mar 12 02 - 3:28pm
df

Not only that, but this season it seems that David contracted gonorrhea from his unprotected one-night stand with said male prostitute. The lady at the clinic even calls him on it, referring to him as a "bad boy." Seems like finger-wagging to me... tongue in cheek yes, but still wagging. PS - this "essay" is what's going above fold with big obnoxious graphics on Nerve.com now? Must be a slow sex month.

Mar 12 02 - 3:48pm
GLP

Well, actually David DID get arrested after the tryst on the hood of a car in Vegas - but due to some crafty police work on the part of the ex., all the charges were dropped. Have to say though your anaylsis is pretty accurate - the only shock value in the sex scenes is the kind given for laughs ie. Nate performing cunnilingus on Brenda in the viewing room and Mom walking in on them!

Mar 12 02 - 4:49pm
EEL

It's nice to see Six Feet Under getting some attention on here. It's such a great show! This article had some errors, but other then that, it was great. ;) I can't wait to see more!

Mar 13 02 - 2:43pm
JG

D'Oh! You guys are totally right -- I did blunder by failing to note David's Vegas arrest. Dumb, dumb. Still, I think the point remains the same, that SFU by and large avoids the sanctimony that too often accompanies sex on TV.
Thank you very much to those who pointed it out.

Mar 14 02 - 3:13pm
daw

Hell YEAH man! This show is the SHIT! Great article. So on point...

Mar 14 02 - 5:08pm
DMB

Well thoughtout take on a terrific show. While Nerve naturally takes a look at the show's approach to sex, Six Feet Under's real daring is in its ubiquitous portrail of death and all -even the mundane - which attend it. Can an episode featuring love in a casket (empty or already occupied!) be far off?

Mar 14 02 - 10:06pm
jh

um. nate took the ecstasy on Six Feet Under, not the mom.

Mar 14 02 - 10:08pm
NDG

I think you've nailed it on this show; Brenda is sooooo hot, and full of surprises....easily in the top 10 shows currently on TV.

Mar 15 02 - 11:40am
ft

the article has it right; the mom did take ecstasy (from the same bottle nate got his; it was left there by david) in season one, when she went camping (remember the bear scene!).

Mar 18 02 - 7:29pm
PL

I like your point about how television producers etc. have that 'look how daring we are' attitude when they are taking a sexual risk in a show.
It's really quite lame that they think like that.
Just do what you gotta do...

Mar 18 02 - 9:17pm
RM

What a fantastic sight--I love it!!

Mar 18 02 - 9:18pm
rm

No--the mom took it too--remember the camping trip?!

Mar 18 02 - 9:20pm
rm

I LUV reachel Griffiths, she is such a great actress--I think her star will just rise and rise, and she is sexy as hell--has anyone seen her in some of the indies she done like "Blowdry"?

Mar 22 02 - 8:01am
DL

Perhaps because I opted to move from a large city to a small town, I'm no longer aware of the current Salon vernacular. This is my first exposure to the superlative "the cat's-ass", which Jason Gay uses to praise the HBO series "Six Feet Under". Might I assume that the award for television programs which receive this new praise-phrase would be a cat-ass-trophy?

Mar 26 02 - 9:24pm
RTC

"pee pee a minute OZ"???? Where the hell did you learn about sex? From Archie and Veronica comix ,jeez grow up a little bit.

Apr 27 02 - 6:53pm
jhp

I'm a huge fan. Especially of Rico - meow!!! The true cat's ass. It's nice to see a yummy Hispanic on TV. Allen Ball wrote the character expecially for Rodriguez, Rico has sex -appeal, family love and a good sense of humor. I love how he thinks about his work as ART.

May 27 02 - 6:50am
SS

Excellent article! This program is among the best ever produced on television. I would however like to see more dick in the series, especially involving Keith and David. I imagine Keith has an enormous penis and I would love to get even just a glimpse of it. *****sigh......*****

Oct 16 02 - 12:26pm
BAO

I just forwarded this article to my boyfriend with the message "wish I wrote this". Six Feet Under is the only show on TV I like and, although I am in the perfect demographic for Sex and the City AND I get as much sex as I want, I still can't stomach that show.

http://tigger.uic.edu/~bethann/

Now you say something

Incorrect please try again
Enter the words above: Enter the numbers you hear: