OPINIONS


 

Because apparently what the world really needs now is a young, perky, semi-intelligent girl named Michel who would like you to help pay for her big shiny new breasts. This is the idea behind giveboobs.com. This is yet another one of those glorious reasons you have DSL and copious free time and an inexhaustible sense of revulsion and awe. This is the sinister, ingenious online begging mini-phenomenon, as originated by savekaryn.com, taken to its next logical, and very nipply, level.
      You might remember Karyn: the blonde, semi-clever, twenty-nine-year-old Brooklyn lass who ostensibly ran up twenty grand in credit card debt and then went online imploring complete strangers to donate to her get-out-of-debt fund because she bought, like, too much pricey makeup at Bergdorf's and too many Prada boots on eBay? And her site was all, like, cute and simple and sincere and stuff? And her shameless, aw-shucks candor about her vacuous spending habits appealed to something sweet and altruistic in many thousands of sufficiently amused Netizens who all sent her a dollar or two or ten?
      According to her site, Karyn collected her twenty grand. All of it. No more debt. Go figure.
      Then, boom: a hundred copycat sites were spawned, everything from yuppie couples begging for cash to pay for their fertility treatments to despondent pleas for help with medical bills. Ed wants a new Hummer. Penny wants help paying for nursing school so she can have a career after she divorces her nice, boring husband. And so it goes, all the way down to the unfunny dumb guy who just wants to be a millionaire and buy BMWs and big-screen plasma TVs and be a drain on the cultural karmic oversoul for about sixty more years.
      And now there's giveboobs.com, one young damsel's attempt to get you, the casual smut-loving boob-attuned Web surfer, to help pay for her boob job because, well, her mom won't fork over the cash. And the surgery is really expensive. And who doesn't love the idea of big, rock-hard cataloupes on tiny five-foot-one girls whom you will never date, much less grope the large, oddly unyielding breasts of? Exactly. She has raised $3,300 so far.
      Michel's site appears to be, at first nipply blush, one part genius, one part sad social commentary, one part sexually empowering yelp of independence, one part proto-feminist sabotage. Or something.
     It is where those icky Cosmo-enabled sexual constructs, those unhealthy and impossibly unrealistic ideals of cheap feminine beauty so loathed by feminists and Oprah, meet perky misguided entrepreneurial spirit. It is a multifaceted minefield of mixed messages. It is quintessential America. Indeed, the site asks one of the most pressing and prescient questions of the day: whom do big hard fake boobs serve more, the proprietor or the populace at large? Who truly derives more pleasure from admittedly shallow but hugely popular acts of plastic surgery? Cutesy, carnally naive Michel, who will henceforth be saddled with increasingly rigid stalactite appendages, or our sexually voracious culture, drunk on heavily airbrushed, buffed and pumped and lipsticked imagery? And hence, who should foot the bill?
      Some dudes might love the idea of giveboobs. Feminists and the sexually attuned might dread and pity it. But is our Michel really the one worthy of such praise or such derision? Where to aim thy finger of ironic lament?
      It's easy to argue that the evil media — the decades of Baywatch and lad's mags and bad porn — should be held responsible and should ultimately pay for every woman's fake boobs — and maybe a few pec implants and hair transplants for the men, too.
      But what to make of the great rallying cry coming from the hordes of freshly boobed American women: Yo, sweetheart, shut up already, they're our bodies. We love our fake boobs, and what's the big deal? Imitation body parts are de rigueur, they cry. There's nothing wrong with wanting to feel better about your appearance, they claim, pointing out how a full three-quarters of all female celebs — not to mention an estimated 137 percent of L.A. and Miami Beach and Vegas — have gone the way of the fake casabas. Along with nips, tucks, collagen, lipo and Botox, fake tits are now considered mere fashion accessories in the modern woman's arsenal, like diamond earrings or gold ankle bracelets or, say, Ben Affleck.
      Unless, of course, that's utter bullshit. Unless you realize what epic amounts of damage hath been wrought upon young women by such messages, how many Prozac prescriptions and bulimia epidemics and Marlboro/salad diets. how many disoriented and denuded seventeen year olds are now cramming the waiting lists of just how many plastic surgeons and psychotherapists.
      But then maybe you think, Oh hell, lighten up already. It's just a dumb little Web site. My inconsequential buck is funding just one pair of fake boobs in an ocean of silicone. It's not like I'm contributing to the downfall of Western civilization or anything, right?
      Unless, you know, you are. Just a little. Just a tiny bit. Unless there's something sort of ugly and sinister beneath the perky giveboobs.com exterior — the idea that you are, essentially, with your one little dollar, casting your vote for the notion of false charity and fake boobs and all they represent, and all the e-begging phenom represents, and really, who needs that ethical fingernail dragged across their karmic chalkboard?
      Sure, giveboobs.com is no big deal. Sure, it's just momentarily entertaining cultural effluvia. Then again, that's what they said about pop-up ads. And AOL. Spam. SUVs. J. Lo.
      Herein the lesson: Never underestimate the power of the tacky, superficial, stolen idea. When not even the needy are truly needy anymore, when the genuinely destitute and distressed (hello, Lyme disease) are eclipsed by the vacuously cute, by the lazy and the boobiciously vain begging you to pay for some pointless thing they don't even need, that they could get themselves if they actually tried and worked and saved, this might be something worth noticing — and worth avoiding. Besides, giveboobs.com certainly, in the end, won't give our lost Michel any sort of priceless lesson on the value of beauty, or sex, or life, or a buck, or a pair of really nice, small breasts, undistended, breathing free, all-natural and organically nipple-riffic.
      Go ahead — reach up, get a nice grip on giveboobs.com. Take a healthy squeeze of the idea. See? You don't really want that, do you? 


©2003 Nerve.com, Inc. and Mark Morford



ABOUT THE AUTHOR:

Mark Morford writes for sfgate.com, the website for the San Francisco Chronicle. He was recently named Best Online Columnist for 2003 by the National Society of Newspaper Columnists. He is also a yoga teacher and fiction writer and an outstanding parallel parker and fervent wine devotee and former L.A. rock-god wannabe and paradoxical contrarian and tattooed love-monkey and ardent dog lover and sincere Astroglide advocate.

Commentarium (32 Comments)

Feb 10 03 - 11:49am
DJB

Loved the article. So pleased to see Mark Morford in Nerve.

I do suspect, however, that you may be missing a close italics tag in your HTML. I don't imagine the author intended to italicize the entire last half of the essay.

Keep up the wonderful work!

Feb 10 03 - 2:50pm
KJ

That site is hysterical..am glad somebody is writing about it in such a humorous and "right on" way.
The writer is great.....where can we read more of his stuff?

Feb 10 03 - 2:53pm
SM

Mark Morford is my dream love god. astroglide abuser and sardonic wit user. Is he single? Does he threesome? Can I lick his toes?
more.......mmm

Feb 10 03 - 5:41pm
EL

Actually, Michel already has the money, she;'s just doing this as some kind of bizarre vote-with-your-dollar stunt.

Besides, what's wrong with women who don't already have breasts getting breasts (or for that matter, what's wrong with with makeup, toupees, acne creams, other cosmetic/reconstructive surgeries, etc.)? Afraid that you can't harass people for looking like freaks anymore if they can actually stop looking freaky?

Feb 10 03 - 5:46pm

Great article! With this intelligent, articulate piece, another voice rises against vulgarity, shallowness and the absurd in today's culture.

Feb 10 03 - 5:46pm
YK

Great article! With this intelligent, articulate piece, another voice rises against vulgarity, shallowness and the absurd in today's culture.

Feb 10 03 - 5:55pm
CD

Hey, you are correct on everything, except that everyone in La-la-land has fake boobies. I am an all-natural C-cup wielding, 5 foot 1 chick! Ha ha! Granted, most men in this town have no idea what real boobs look or feel like. Oh well.

Feb 10 03 - 6:33pm
gw

Exposure is the currency of our time, and whether it's negative or positive makes lil' difference. So, printin', postin', uploadin' this story just hastens her new headlights...

BUT, she wus already well on her way to the ta-ta total, so yer intelligent remarks were at least good readin'...thank you.

xoxo,
Gu$
www.WhiteHotTrash.com

Feb 10 03 - 6:48pm
lc

I appreciated the authors viewpoint, especially being that the author was a man. Thanks.

Feb 10 03 - 8:31pm
EAD

I just wanted to commend you on this article. So much of what I read on this site is just another slice of pop culture, dressed up with an attitude to make it seem like a witty too-cool observation of "actual" pop culture.

Your article was a breath of fresh air. Thank you for being horrified, thank you for being upset and disturbed. I'm glad I'm not the only one who feels slightly ill at the extent to which we've twisted ourselves around.

Feb 10 03 - 9:14pm
kn

Brilliant! This is an issue very close to my heart, as well as other chest-related parts. I wear a DDD cup, and trust me, big breasts are not worth it. Lack of clothing in my size, leers from jackasses, and chronic back pain are the only things I've ever gotten from them. I'm hoping to save up money for a reduction soon; I have medical grounds for one. But this pop-culture idea that the body can and should be sliced and squeezed into society's ideal shape has got to go. There are far too many high school juniors with nose jobs.

Feb 10 03 - 10:15pm
MN

Hmm...the "There are far too many high school juniors with nose jobs" comment would be credible if it came from someone talking about her own *nose*, not about her own breasts. Unfortunately, kn merely leaves the impression that she feels threatened by people obtaining even prettier noses than her own (kinda hard to make fun of people born with "weird" noses if you can't tell which ones they are, isn't it?).

Feb 10 03 - 10:51pm
CT

The reason I love to live in this country is to read articles like Mark

Feb 10 03 - 11:06pm
mjp

The thought never occured to me to feel "threatened" by a junior high-schooler with a nose job. What I do feel is pity and shame for a society that convinces a healthy person (thirteen years old or otherwise) that they need to go to incredibly drastic measures to "fix" a body part that was never broken in the first place. I had breast reduction myself because I was a 38DDD and couldn't sleep without muscle spasms in my back, severe pain, etc (i.e.- a real reason for surgery). On the other hand, I choose to keep my ethnic and very 'Jewish' nose because it is mine. Period. Nobody will convince me that it is not beautiful because I will not let them. We DO have that power, by the way- to not be swayed by pop culture telling us what we should and shouldn't look like.

Feb 11 03 - 12:47am
QT

KN, what the hell is wrong with you?! Stop being so shallow and cutesy and carnally naive and lost. Don't let some quack surgeon wacko slice and dice you into society's ideal shape. Don't care what any other person thinks! It's all BULLSHIT (because it's only OK for women like ME, BORN with the genes for C-cups, to find clothes in our sizes and avoid leers from jackasses...admit it, you and Michel - even genius Mark can't say she's pretty the way she is - are just naturally less deserving)!

Feb 11 03 - 10:47am
ll

Loved this article - nice to hear that perspective coming from a guy. There is hope for humanity, after all.

Feb 12 03 - 1:40am
PRT

All this cleavage is a godsend to men who love big breasts. In contrast, many porn videos feature women with natural breasts, no "boob jobs" in sight. I like perky real breasts too and my girlfriend loves to rub her erect nipples on my chest as a reward for being so talented with her nipples-licking and caressing her "ladies" as she tweaks mine. Our foreplay includes cock tip to nipple fun leading up to very hot intercourse after 69 fun in front of a mirror.

Feb 11 03 - 2:57pm
jr

wow! what a fab take on how the psuedo craze kills pure pleasure. i relish every hilarious word. i wonder, though -- does morford have a gf with droopy boobs? cellulite? jowls? i doubt it.

Feb 11 03 - 9:54pm
Marx

I think that Mark is 100% right on. But isn't there some incongruity between someone thinking that they're physically inadequate but, at the same time, that they're deserving of my money? The real problem is vanity - not only do these people want to have it all, but they think that they're so special that they're going to get us to pay for it. My children will have to earn their prosthetics the American way, struggling under a sachel of Rupert Murdoch's newspapers every morning.

Feb 11 03 - 10:00pm
KT

Does anyone else think giveboobs is just a scam? Aside from the whole begging on the Internet thing, I find it ridiculous that people would contribute money to a cause that has no way of verifying to its contributors its own legitimacy. For all we know, Michel could be a Michael just scamming people. Repeated emails by yours truly to Michel asking for proof, evidence, etc. have been ignored.

Apparently my serious emails aren't fun enough for her to address.

Feb 12 03 - 1:52pm
KLK

Loved the article! Really made me think-thats good!

Feb 12 03 - 10:49am
AS

Oh please. People have always done things to make themselves look better. This is just another one of them. Maybe it's another two century fad, like corsets. What makes your moral/ethical code the one that everyone has to abide by? The one that decides that those who don't follow it are contributing to the downfall of our culture? I'm a guy, and I would rather not date a women with fake breasts, but I am not going to stop or criticize anyone.

Feb 12 03 - 6:52pm
amb

If a gal wants implants, she's gonna get implants. Hell, I wanted implants for a while. I just wanted to have a normal figure and fit into dresses without having to hem the chest. My mom, aunt, cousin among others have them, it practically runs in the family. And then I found out about how my mom had to replace her's a couple of times. Those things don't exactly last forever. After all she told me, it doesn't exactly worth it in the long run. It's like getting a tattoo...you're gonna be stuck with it for the rest of your life, so it better not be a passing phase of you're gonna be sorry. So, I leared to love my own boobs...and then started taking a new birth control pill that boosted me a whole cup size!

Feb 14 03 - 3:21pm
RCV

Thought it was a funny concept, but I like them natural, regardless of size. I clicked "No".

Feb 18 03 - 9:58pm
jsg

great piece. i think this boob should be locked in a closet with the credit card girl and many starving angry children who lost their jobs making those ugly shoes. will the many short small breasted women of the world please get a clue? you're perfect! (provided you dont wear those awful shoes!)
in fact, there of some of us who dream about you and all the fun we could have because you're so little...
cancer and painful orthopedic problems. whoopee!

Feb 19 03 - 3:03pm
jen

Wow, great article regarding a mildly horrific concept - I'm so dependent upon other people's opinion of me I am having complete strangers vote upon and fund my new tits! How about tossing out all those "women's" magazines, instead? It will save you a lot of time, money and heartache. I learned to do so when I was about 18, and it has made a world of difference in my self esteem.

One comment to some of those posting feedback - the whole "you must not want ugly people to have plastic surgery because then you couldnt make fun of them" argument... hello?! The very people against surgery are the ones promoting the novel concept that you are beautiful just the way you are. It may be hard for you to swallow, but some people arent total tools of the media they consume. The ones serving up that argument are the ones who have such rigid standards of beauty, and are probably MUCH more likely to make fun of someone's nose than the ones saying "honey you are beautiful the way you are!"

Feb 22 03 - 7:01am

hi,sexy girl,you are so...

Feb 24 03 - 1:43pm

tell back to me 09-8634272
my name is max bexer

Feb 24 03 - 1:47pm
hal

that was absolutely great. thanks.

Aug 24 03 - 1:57am
L.B.

A short while after my baby sis got her boob job she saw 60 minutes and HER PLASTIC SURGEON WAS THE TARGET! Ha ha ha...sad but true...I hate fake boobs cuz they are SO fake! At least with a nose job if you didnt know the person before you would never know unless they told you.

Oct 01 10 - 7:34pm
keymaker

Hello boys, I am Sandra and I want to write my little commentary. I am want to place your text at my personal blog, with link to your blog. Is it normal for your? give to me your answer, please.

Now you say something

Incorrect please try again
Enter the words above: Enter the numbers you hear: