PERSONAL ESSAYS



In the Realm of the Sansei by David Mura  






Recently a Vietnamese-American friend was giving a talk at a local college about Asian-American sexual politics. He pointed out the commonplace that while Asian and Asian-American women — from the geisha in Madame Butterfly to the bar girls in Miss Saigon — are seen as sensual, exotic creatures, Asian men are typically seen as unattractive, even sexless.


    

The class was mainly white, with a few Asian Americans and African Americans. They protested that this was an overstatement. My friend asked if any of them had ever found an Asian man attractive.


    

No one raised their hand.


    

To me, this shouldn't be surprising. Growing up Japanese in 1950s America, I never saw an image of an attractive Asian man, much less a Japanese-American man like me. Instead, the heroes and great lovers were all white: Cary Grant, Jimmy Stewart, Clint Eastwood, Sean Connery, Marlon Brando. In those years, the typical image of a Japanese male was Mickey Rooney as the buck-toothed, mop-topped bespectacled photographer, screaming at Holly Golightly in Breakfast at Tiffany's, angry at her for constantly ringing his doorbell.


    

"Miss Go-rightry, Miss Gorightry, I plotest."


    

"Oh quiet, you little man. If you promise to be good, I'll let you take those pictures you asked about."



    

I grew up in a white, predominantly Jewish suburb of Chicago. I was a sansei (third generation Japanese American); I knew no Japanese and spoke with a pronounced Midwestern accent. In high school, I only wanted to date white girls. I saw being with other Asian-American girls as something that was expected of me, and something that relegated me to a secondary status. I wanted to prove that I was as good as the white guys.


    

It was only after college that I began to go to Japanese movies and see images of Japanese men as heroes, lovers and sexual beings. I had little in common culturally with these figures. But, subtly, they began to alter my own feelings about myself in ways I wouldn't be able to articulate until years later.


    

The first Japanese actor I discovered was Toshiro Mifune, the great Japanese star of the post-war period, known for such films as The Seven Samurai and Yojimbo. The ultimate samurai, Mifune often portrayed a ronin, a wanderer without a master or

clan. He had no attachments, and his strength lay in the fact that he did not give in to emotions or desires. Always in complete

control, Mifune kept his wits honed to a razor's edge. He might flirt with the ladies-in-waiting or the courtesans in the castle, but he never lost himself in either love or sexual desire. Such stoicism, his films implied, was the ultimate in sexual power.


    

In the '60s, one of Mifune's counterparts in Japanese cinema was Zatoichi, the blind samurai, a fat, wobbling man who miraculously fought off the hordes of ninjas who were forever ambushing him. Zatoichi ate like a pig and made love the same way, like an animal, like a beast rutting. I took from him a different message: in Japan, even ugly guys get laid.


    

A third image for me came from the movie In The Realm of the Senses. Released in 1976, it represented part of a sexual revolution that was taking place all across the globe, only with a Japanese twist. Based on a true story, the film depicts a sexually obsessive love affair between a Japanese man and a woman in the 1930s. In one scene, the couple watch a group of soldiers tramp across a bridge. Amid the rise of fascism and militarism in Japan, the lovers remain set apart in a silent protest of passion. In their

heightening sexual experimentation, they begin asphyxiating each other to enhance their sexual pleasure. Things escalate and finally, in a fit of lust or madness or both, the woman chokes the man to death. She then (famously) slices off his penis, clutches it to her chest and carries it through the streets of Tokyo. Watching this, I felt that her devotion arose in part from the man's absolute willingness to put himself at her mercy. His sexuality came not from either stoicism or hyper-masculinity, but from giving in to the woman's sexual appetites and power.



    

I often wonder if any real progress has been made towards a better understanding of the sexuality of Asian men. In Western eyes, are we still just stereotyped geeks and businessmen, or has the recent success of Chinese actors like Jackie Chan and Chow Yun Fat helped re-sexualize all Asian men? I wonder how many Americans are aware of Mifune, Mishima or In the Realm of the Senses? Do attractive Caucasian women who pass me on the street register my glance? Do they register me?


    

My wife, who is white, grew up with little, if any, knowledge of Japanese or Asian culture. She did, though, grow up in a household with many international visitors, and her father traveled all over the globe. After years of my prodding her about her attraction to me in terms of my ethnic heritage, my wife finally said, "I think I grew up feeling that to be with a white guy would be a bit boring. But being with someone black was still taboo. You were other, but not too other."


    

Yes, I told her, that's part of it. But why Asian? Why not Latino? What does it mean to you that I'm a Japanese American?


    

She smiled, slightly exasperated. "Oh David, I don't know."



    

Once in a poem I referred to a traditional fertility rite I had seen in a photograph of Japan: A line of women in kimono and geta, each holding a daikon radish carved to the shape of a penis, marching through the streets of their village. Various members of my all-white graduate workshop objected to the image as sexist, even misogynist. I didn't bother to try to explain what the ritual might hold for me. In that room, there was only one way of reading, one vision of proper sexuality, and it did not include me.


    

Recalling this incident, I think of the way the woman in In the Realm of the Senses worships her lover's penis, coos to it, talks to it jealously and possessively. They make love repeatedly, drenching each other in the sweat of their bodies and their sexual emissions. They don't let the chambermaid change their bedding or intrude on their private realm, shut off by shoji [paper doors], and their own imaginative intensity.


    

Wrapping a scarf around his neck, twisting it to heighten his orgasm,

she leads him further into oblivion, a blackout just this side of death. The woman murmurs that she feels him jump inside her. She is lost in her own pleasure and feels herself at one with his.


    

But then their climax subsides, and they are back in their bodies, no longer one but two. She calls to him. He doesn't respond. She slides off and then cups him in her palm. It takes her several moments to realize he is dead.


    

After she takes her final possession, she writes her love in blood upon his chest. She wanders out in the rainy, night-stained streets. There are no gaijin [foreigners], no hakujin [whites]. There is only her gaze and the memory of his gaze. There is only night in Tokyo, as the city sleeps.


    

I keep these images as a talisman. Though I will never know nor enter this foreign world, I return to it in my mind because it is a picture of desire that seems familiar to me: his body resembles mine, his darkness resembles mine, his face resembles mine, his penis resembles mine.


    

But the other world always intrudes. My world. The one I live and love in, where I'm still trying to understand what it is I desire. And how, despite it all, she desires me.


    









For a complete list of content in the Sex in Japan Issue, read the


Introduction.



©2000 David Mura and Nerve.com

Commentarium (19 Comments)

Mar 28 00 - 3:58pm
GM

I have fantasized about Asian men since I can remember. I have had only two Asian lovers,one chinese and the other vietnamese -french. And countless crushes. I liked how experimental both lovers were, how beautiful and free and absolutely sensual I felt when making love with them.
"In the realm of the senses" was the first "Taboo" film I ever watched.

Mar 28 00 - 5:27pm
aew

Au contraire, my friend. There are some of us Caucasian women out there who find Asian men downright irresistable. Especially when they're articulate and dressed sharply. (pant pant)

Mar 28 00 - 11:49pm
SB

Umm, I have no idea why, but I've always had a fascination with Asian men. Also Native American men.Dark-haired, dark-eyed, slender yet powerful, mysterious, holders of a secret power. I guess it takes a lot from images of Asian men in martial-arts films. The hidden power behind the face of respectability and the age behind the appearance of youth(you know, the slim, hairless body typical of Asian men)--the implication of sensitivity, passion, stoicism, and power together were very appealing to me. Unfortunately I fell in love with a tall, hairy, slightly pudgy white guy, but oh well. I'm glad I read this article. Tonight I'll fantasize about kung fu warriors and ronin. Good article.

Mar 28 00 - 11:56pm
SB

Additional comment: I guess the mystique of Asian men is American women's reaction to the annoyingly ubiquitous macho expectations of manhood that dominate this society. American masculinity is so over the top, out of control, and completely self-centered. Asian masculinity--kind of a modern gentleman's masculinity in this context--has a greater awareness of others, which is appealing to us white gals sick to death of being tuned out and left behind (socially and sexually) when we don't focus our entire attention on the exploits of the Rugged Individual Tough Guy made-in-America brand of man and alter our appearance to meet his expectations.

...no, I'm not bitter. ;)

Mar 29 00 - 9:51am
M

Excellent article on a fascinating subject - several cuts above the usual crap on Nerve (but there is enough of this caliber that I keep reading :-) I plan on rereading it. However, I'd like to point out to Mr. Mura that Toshiro Mifune needs little explanation to American movie fans - he has to be the most famous crossover from Japanese cinema. I knew who he was from American movies even before I saw him in any of his Japanese films. (I guess Pat Morita doesn't count...)

Mar 31 00 - 3:20pm
ay

i don't think that there has been that much progress in the way americans view asian males. jackie chan and those others don't really help either because they don't speak english.
however i think that gay whit men find asian boys attractive. so if you're a gay asian boy then that's not a problem. for everyone else, there won't be that much progress in the next century.

Apr 02 00 - 8:59am
lcc

A recent Newsweek reported that Asian men are the hot new cool thing, and now the white women want them. The following week's letters section was filled mostly with AsianAmerican men saying Why should my worth or coolness be determined by how many WHITE WOMEN want me? True. In reading this Nerve article's feedback, I see white (I assume) women saying Asian men are sexy because they're secret, powerful, lithe. (I'm guilty of saying all that too. I even once said it's sexy how good they are at math -- yikes!) That's like saying I like white women because they're statuesque and blonde and bold. I don't know how "secret" an AsianAmerican feels to himself or his family. And what if he's chubby? How does it feel, I wonder, to be sought after not for what you are, but for what you are not (ie., a big hairy white regular man)?

Apr 02 00 - 12:38pm
ecs

I grew up n Hawai'i. And it was always known that haole (white) students seemed to always date Asian or Polynesian school friends, and vice versa for local students. We wanted to meet new and interesting (and no doubt "exotic")students. Yeah, grandmothers were probably against all this (I mean I had one friend whose family from the main island of Japan did not want her dating Hokkaido students) and I thought BUT THEY'RE BOTH JAPANESE!

My children are hapa-haole (half Asian). And demographically the fastest growing race in Hawai'i is hapa-haoles. How sad that on the mainland (where we now live) it is so very different. Hawai'i is more than an Island State, it is another world all together in very many important ways. Know that some of us have ALWAYS felt that Asian men were VERY VERY attractive! Aloha nui loa.

Apr 04 00 - 9:03am
hg

Hi
I just wonder if Mr. Mura is aware that there was three versions made called "In the Realm of the Senses". All three concentrated upon the geisha found wandering the streets clutching a bag with her lover's penis inside.

All three approach the story from different viewpoints. Oshima's version focuses on the destructive powers of lust, and this is also parralleled in his next film, "the Empire of the Senses". The other one that I remember, concentrates upon the life of the geisha who searches for the love that was missing in her life. Despondant at the death of her last lover, she retains the penis so as not to again lose this love. The 3rd film again had a psychological bent to it, but I can't quite remember it's point.

I'm surprised that Mr. Mura didn't mention the sexual charisma of Seiji Ozawa. He just vibrates with sexuality.

Apr 11 00 - 3:05pm
IC

While I was glad to read David Mura's honest musings on a hugely undiscussed topic, I thought that, sadly, he was ultimately too meek on the matter. Asian male sexuality (in America) was in trouble the moment the first Chinese immigrant cooked his first chop suey for his white customer or washed his first pair of britches for a New World colonist. Our bodies, next to Anglo Saxon stock, do not carry the same muscle mass or fat content. As a rule, we do not make catcalls, or puff out our chests at every opportunity and we tend to favor lives of domesticity and geeky contemplation. Power, in this Western world, was (and still is) cut from a different cloth, and so too, the locus of sexuality.

Examples of Asian male sexuality abound in the East, as it should: bawdiness, pornography, and other hallmarks of the male libido are everywhere in Asia, encompassing all sexualities, no less. I would, however, like to highlight a couple of forgotten examples (in addition to Mura's) of the sexual Asian male in the West: Tony Leung in Anaud's L'Amant and Bruce Lee, particularly in Return of the Dragon. Leung's performance, as well as the opportunity granted by Duras and Anaud, speaks for itself.

Lee's oft-neglected work in Return of the Dragon, however, deserves much closer attention. There is a scene where Bruce, having just arrived FOB in Rome, sits in a piazza outside with Nora Miao, where she is lecturing him on the cultural differences between the Chinese and Italians. All the while, a beautiful Italian brunette sits down next to the two and begins making eyes at Bruce and smiles at him. The scene changes abruptly to Bruce climbing the stairs to Nora's apartment, where he is staying, and one of his friends from the restaurant where he is working emerges from within and asks him where he has been. There is an absurdly long pause as Bruce says nothing and smiles (post-coitally perhaps?) to the camera and the scene ends.

Bruce laid the foundation, but who will build on his legacy?

Apr 22 00 - 8:35am
T

Hmph! You clearly haven't seen the films of Shintaro Katsu's brother, Wakayama Tomisaburo. In "Lone Wolf and Cub" or even in "Irezumi", or "Shinkai" or countless others, Wakayama-san creates a man who is strong, incredibly disciplined at his art, with great heart and a sense of humor and sadness. I think he was intensely sexy, and I'm an African/American woman!

May 21 00 - 6:34am
sc

If Hollywood ruled the world, Asian men would be almost extinct and those left would be walking eunuchs. There are hardly any Asian men visible on the big screen especially sexy Asian men. And Jackie Chan is hardly re-sexualizing Asian men unless you think goofy Chinese guys with bad accents are sexy. The most recent Asian actors that appeared sexy are Russel Wong and the late Brandon Lee. Of course Russel Wong looks more Caucasian than Asian and Brandon Lee IS half-Caucasian.

I am Asian and I have dated many white women. I always wondered why they wanted to date an Asian guy and how they could find me attractive. I know I was deeply influenced by the media and I chased after the white feminine beauty, which I had considered truly desirable. So why didn't they chase that hot White or Black guy portrayed so well on the big screen? I grew up not believing that I was good looking because I am not White or Black.

Jun 26 00 - 4:17pm
GM

I like your story and I can fully understand your questions about your own sexuality and what you might be in the eyes of women. I have to say that I find Asian men attractive, maybe nowadays taste has changed towards foreign people. For example black women can be very successful top models. I am a white girl and I live in Germany with an Italian man.

Aug 05 00 - 6:13am
adn

All told, this article confronted very little. From my point of view, Asian-American men have a huge angle on sex appeal, because I'm in subcultures that are attracted to japanese glamour: historic japanese dress, the toys and cartoons of japan, etc. I wasn't surprised at all when Star Wars' Queen Amidala used eastern glamour -- it has been hip for quite a while in nerd scenes. But then, in mass culture white is best, but in subcultures white is the least interesting. Japan probably has it the luckiest of all the asians on that count, in fact -- I feel sorrier for a random Vietnamese, although probably most people don't even know the difference. In the circles I travel, and I bet in a circle like Nerve, you'd find many people who are MORE annoying for the cheapness of their attraction to Asians, aka "yellow fever," than people ignorant about it. Most of the people I've found sexiest are Asians... Jackie Chan and Brigitte Lin Ching-Hsia are two that come to mind. Anyway, it sounds like you and your wife didn't very well escape from the stereotypes that drove your sexual anxiety---you said dating white chicks made you feel as good as whitey, and she said you were dangerous but not too dangerous. Not exactly the authorities on resisting race-attractiveness stereotypes.

Sep 14 00 - 8:56pm
JYCC

I am a Canadian male of Chinese heritage who was born and raised in Vancouver in a white neighbourhood.
Your article brought back memories when I attended discussion groups with other oriental males on what it was to be oriental in white society. There were so many ideas, and there were no conclusions, just experience sharing and I suspect being oriental in white society is whatever you want it to be.
I have only been with white women mainly because they were the only ones around. I'm with a women because of her personality and not her ethnic origin. I think they're with me because I interest them. Why I interest them may be difficult to answer. Could be because I'm new, or different or because I'm a nice guy.

When I was in high school I was not popular, did not date and I was probably not sexually appealing. I was quite concerned. This all changed when I met a Quebec woman travelling through Vancouver. When we travelled to Quebec I got more attention from women there than I got in Vancouver.

Bruce Lee was the most powerful and sexual Asian male image I had when I was a teen. I avoided many fights because of the ruboff respect I got from him.
In Winnipeg, where I was a teaching assistant, I got so much sexual attention I was overwhelmed. I was involved with a native woman there, a first.
Today I'm back in Vancouver and I've met Japanese women who are interesting sexually.

To conclude, I can say if you're not getting sexual attention, say in high school, don't fret, it'll come. There is no one standard for what is sexual and what turns one on may not do it for another.

The main sexual attractor for me is who the person is, how they carry themself and what I can contribute to that person. Trust and communication are a big part. There are so many people who are physically interesting, but lack the psychology or emotion to warrant a tryst. I do not question whether I'm sexually attractive - it is a non question.

Just be, go out and play the game.

Love,

JYCC
Van, BC

May 07 02 - 1:02pm
LM

Your article was thought-provoking and excellent. I learned a lot about Japanese films. "In the Realm of the Senses" sounds so shocking, I am glad that if I ever get a chance to see it, I know the ending. I appreciate your honesty. I know some people jumped on you, but I have no reason to. As a white female, I love Asian culture and find Asian men very sexually desirable. My first serious boyfriend was Vietnamese. I always thought I would end up marrying one, but my husband is from West Africa.

Aug 14 02 - 8:26pm
RL

Mr. Mura,
There is a generation in America that do think of Asians as sexy and even more, but I am not sure if it from the sucess of the aforementioned actors or if it is something else. I for one have never thought of the Japanese as business men in suits or geeks. Your culture is beautiful and you should be proud I only wish I could learn everything about it in this live time. In closing I have really enjoyed your article.
Thank you,
Rachel Larson

Nov 20 11 - 8:57pm
Taimi

Not bad at all fellas and gaalls. Thanks.

Now you say something

Incorrect please try again
Enter the words above: Enter the numbers you hear: