Not a member? Sign up now
| PERSONAL ESSAYS |
|
|
||
|
In 1998, while in Los Angeles for the filming of Fight Club, I went with friends to the Getty Museum. All those antiquities, the decorative objects, all the galleries of stuff being looked at by hushed tourists, my friends and me. That endless parade of masterpieces, it was too much. Grinding, the way a day of yard sales can be grinding as your eyes find a name for each object, a place in history, a story. Too many famous stories butted together on that hilltop above Los Angeles.
Of course, I turned that day into a story.
In the 1970s, during my childhood, museums were more hands-on. You went to galleries to destroy fine art. You took a sledgehammer and mashed the nose of the Pieta. Or you kissed a picture and left lipstick. You tried to spray paint the Mona Lisa, or planted a bomb that would trash some Miros. These days, of course, the Getty had guards and Plexiglas and motion detectors.
So wandering with my friends, I asked them: "Instead of stealing or attacking established art — what if some frustrated artist tried to sneak his paintings into the world's museums?" This artist would paint each picture, matte and frame it, put two-sided mounting tape on the back and wrap the picture inside his trench coat. He'd arrive like us, then open his coat and stick his work on a wall, right there among the Picassos and Renoirs.
This little yarn became a short story called "Ambition" and a screenplay. The story, about an artist desperate to find his place in history, I wrapped into a novel called Haunted.
This May, "Ambition" and Haunted will be published.
On March 13, the Metropolitan Museum of Art found a lovely, gold-framed portrait of a woman wearing a gas mask, stuck on the wall of their gallery. On March 16, the Brooklyn Museum found a portrait of an eighteenth-century military officer holding a can of spray paint. The Museum of Modern Art found a painting on March 17, depicting a can of cream-of-tomato soup. The Louvre and the Tate museums have found similar paintings stuck on their walls.
According to the New York Times, this is the work of a British graffiti artist named Banksy, who wears a trench coat and fake beard as he hangs his work among the masterpieces.
A coincidence? Or, are we more the same person than we'd like to admit? My thoughts are so much
|
Are we more the same person than we'd like to admit?
|
your thoughts that they hardly qualify as mine. The darkest fantasy you keep buried, someone else will get rich, singing about on the radio.
Is it better to hide your dark idea and hope that all other people do the same, or to depict and share that dark idea?
While writing Fight Club, I talked to friends about the idea of a movie projectionist splicing porn into family films. One friend told me not to use the idea, saying it would prompt people to salt porn into everything. When the book was published, countless people wrote to tell me they'd already been splicing sex into Disney films, pissing into restaurant food, or starting fight clubs. For decades.
Still, do we do more damage when we share our dark fantasies – when we explore them through a story or song or picture? Or when we deny them?
Stories are how human beings digest their lives: by making events into something we can repeat and control, telling them until they're exhausted. Until they no longer get a laugh or gasp or teary eye. Until we can absorb, assimilate even those worst events. Our culture, it digests events by making lesser and lesser versions of the original. After a ship sinks or a bomb explodes — the Original Tragedy — then we have the news version, the television movie version, the talk radio versions, the blog versions, the video game, the Franklin Mint Commemorative Plate versions, the McDonalds Happy Meal version, the one-liner reference on The Simpsons. Echoes that fade.
Then, like the funny story you used to tell at parties, the story that would always get laughs, about how you took acid and ate half a fur coat one night, we stop telling that story. NOT because it stops making people laugh — but because we've digested the event. It's resolved, and telling that story in any form no longer serves the teller.
Maybe why Radiohead no longer plays "Creep" in concert.
Maybe it's why we dream — compulsively telling stories, processing our experience like the food in our guts, even while we sleep.
But the stories we're afraid to tell, to control, to craft — they never wear out, and they kill us.
At least this is what I tell my friends when they ask me to shut up. To not give people any new ideas. This is my story about telling stories about telling stories. My way to digest what I do.
I tell people: The sooner we can tell a story, the quicker we can wear it out and make it a cliché, then the less power the idea will have.
Until the past century, religions used to give us a place to tell even our worst stories. Depict our most-terrible intentions. Once each week, you could turn your sins into a story and tell them to your peers. Or to a leader, who'd forgive you and accept you back into your community. Each week, you confessed, you were forgiven, and you received communion. You never strayed too far outside the group because you had this regular release. Maybe the most important aspect of salvation is having this forum, this permission and audience, for expressing our lives as a story.
|
It would be a forum safe enough for you to look terrible.
|
But as church becomes a place where people go to look good — instead of being the one, safe place where they could risk looking bad — we're losing that regular storytelling forum. And the salvation, redemption and communion it allows.
Instead, now people go to therapy groups, twelve-step recovery groups, chat rooms, phone-sex hotlines, even writers workshops, to turn their lives and crimes into stories, express them, craft them, and in doing so be recognized by their peers. Brought back into the flock for another week. Accepted.
With this in mind: Our need to turn even the darkest parts of life — especially the darkest parts — into stories… our need to tell those stories to our peers… and our need to be heard, forgiven and accepted by our community . . . how about we start a new religion?
We could call this the "Church of Story." It would be a performance place where people could exhaust their stories, in words or music or sculpture. A school where people could learn craft skills that would give them more control over their story, and thus their life. This would be a place where people could step out of their lives and reflect, be detached enough to recognize a boring pattern or irrational fears or a weak character and begin to change that. To edit and rewrite their future. If nothing else, this could be a place where people would vent and be heard, and at that point maybe move forward.
It would be a forum safe enough for you to look terrible. Express terrible ideas.
In modern history, frustrated, powerless people have turned to churches. During the last years of segregation, people found each other in churches and recognized they weren't alone. Their personal problems were not only their own.
This "Church of Story" would give people a forum for connecting. Here, we'd have a regular time and place and permission to tell stories to each other. Instead of ignoring this need or fulfilling it at Starbucks in the window of time created by a cappuccino — or wearing a fake beard and gluing our story on the wall of an art gallery — we could give people the permission and structure they need to gather. To tell stories. To tell better stories. To tell great stories. To live great lives. n°
©2005 Chuck Palahniuk and Nerve.com
| ABOUT THE AUTHOR: | |
|
Chuck Palahniuk's novels are the bestselling Lullaby and Fight Club, which was made into a film by director David Fincher, Survivor, Invisible Monsters, and Choke. His most recent and bestselling novel is the acclaimed Diary. He lives in Portland, Oregon. |







Commentarium (31 Comments)
As you say, people find what they need. The new Church of Story exists and it's on the internet (where else?) It's called fanfiction, and there are thousands of stories by people usiing characters they love to tell stories about what they're thinking and wanting to do that they could never do or tell in real life.
I'm waiting for fiction to re-enter the realm of fiction- no autobiography expurgations, no dark fantasies fictionalized, no escapist fantasies turned into storylines. Why "fiction" authors believe that what happens in their lives and within their heads is so much more interesting than anyone else around them, I'll never know. It's as if they were never validated and write in order to be.
Sabra Wineteer
The Church of Stories already exists--it's called daytime tv. Watch Oprah; "every story is worth telling." Telling a story well is another thing. I would definitely go to the church if there were a few good tellers.
Church, Christian or otherwise, works as you describe because most of the people there agree on the story, find it instructive, inspiring, comforting. - Justin
Maybe what is envisioned here is something a bit more interactive than watching telly. Work with the man here, people, instead of just sourly pointing out that Oprah has already done this - i mean, how many people PARTICIPATE on Oprah or the like, versus how many that watches it? Besides, there is the commercial aspect. The internet is great, but not too physical. How about something a bit more communal in spirit, with no cameras, existing in the moment - how would one go about that?
This piece is beautiful. Palahniuk manages to describe the need for communication, confession and carthesis without using those sterile terms. Maybe frightening stories can make the world feel like a safe place.
Churches are places people go just to look good? Not in my experinece.
Thank you, CP.
wonderful words.
I believe I was born into a church similar to the one he mentions. Every artist has probably exerienced something like it -
I have always danced stories, written stories, and listened to stories. My mother works with native american story telling traditions. We both work with community dance where we gather people and turn their stories into performance. People are really - I think - desperate for a Place to express themselves. Rather than a new religion, story telling could be the oldest religion of all. Everything is based in stories.
I went to Catholic mass almost every week for over 20 years. One of its biggest selling points for me, ever since I was very young, was the fact that I got to listen to roughly 3 stories in an hour. For free.
Nice article by the way. I thought it lost a little force in the delivery of the proposal, but maybe that's a length issue. I would like to read a longer piece by CP about this.
Stories are dishonest: I'll stick with my "Fight Club." I kicked it up a notch, though, because punching doesn't have the same impact here in Iraq that it seems to in the Western world.
Naturally, I call it "Bomb, Shoot, and Decapitate Club." My chapter organizes combat catharsis in Baghdad. Anyone want to handle it down in Najaf?
I'm glad you have taken well to the present state of your story. But it lacks depth...kind of like a Slyvester Stallone flick or a repeat airing of Hee Haw. Shoot and maim,write a book....You know I bet your promotional marketing could benefit from something as classy as I'm sure your story is, Infomercials.
Chuck,
I've been a big fan of yours for a while. I've read all of your novels. You even sent me a power rhino for Christmas last year. I just wanted to say: What a great idea! Should this idea ever get off the ground, you can be sure that I'll be a member of the parish.
I have visited the Church of story frequently. Only when the congregation is a singular figure does it satisfy.A congregation consisting of more than the self reproduces the "to be seen " ethos transcending sanctuaries of religious worship.
Great writers are always quirky. I know this. I get the impression you are a fettishist in the most commonly applied sense. I wonder if I am right!
FYI, Chuck lives in Washington now, might want to update the bio ;-)
I work in a bookstore. And I love fiction. But every single day I find myself pulled, like I'm in a slow river, into the biography section. That is where I always find the most interesting stories.
thank you
shit, someone else already said that
If nothing else, an interesting concept. Chuck infallibly tickles the cognition within our core. He certainly has a way with words.
"Church" should be extracted from the title of this new religious sect because it sends a mixed, unclear and conflicting message, I say.
-E.J. Mc Gee - N.Y, NY
Funny, while reading this I immediately thought of bars/pubs and how they act as a kind of meeting house for the unofficial church of story. Everybody has their regular spots and when he or she isn't going out of their way to generate romantic interest it turns into story time with familiar friends or intriguing randoms. Is the experience cheapened by people being under the influence or is it no worse than, say, south american tribes using hallucinatory drugs to commune with the Gods?
That'd be/is a great idea.
Personally, I've never cared for religion & am sickened by the continual flogging of that old horse Jesus('s story in its many guises); granted there are other religions, one which has become the vieweing of "It's a wonderful life" around the 'holidays' when they ought to be playing "Vertigo" instead, or something new, some new stories, but yes, which is why the rising popularity of poetry slams & other story-telling times for communal sharing at bars, clubs & church basements.
Chuck applies fantasy to every day living---the main reason for my adoration of his creativity.
"A Church of Stories" is like a build-up of repressed thought that finally releases from the tightly woven devises that keep the innocent meek and the killer illusive. I would have a difficult time holding it all inside, if it weren't for the art of my poetry. It is said, that even the inhuman ingestion of a computer, can only take in so much information, before it finally spews its waste. The human mind can also store a great deal of experiences, but what is one to do with experiences, if not for the ability to share them with others. Some of life's most dark and outrageous thoughts have also become its most beautiful, illustrated only by the countless manifestations of artistic expression. So, open your soul, and bear the taboos of your passion. And yes, there is a difference between painting ones thoughts and carrying them out.
Secretbard
Dear Chuck:
Interesting thesis .. here's the thing though .. we already spend more money and importantly time on Media as a religion(Cable, Internet, Communications/Cel-Tel Phones, books, gaming, etc) than we do on any religion. Media already allows individuals to self publish .. and if the idea is worthy enough it gains traction on a huge level. The religion you speak of is already here .. it's bigger than any 1 billion people under one house .. it's Media .. and like it or not .. it's a steam roller and leveler ..
Aloha,
Jonathan
what he said. ah the stories people tell on facebook alone...
i think that if i had free right to pick any religion i would pick this one. i would.
Me too...oh wait! I can! And did! I believe my life will be happy and satisfying as long as I keep sharing my stories,and my heart won't be so heavy when the poor saps lower me into that pine!
Your writing is simple great, Especially for beginners!
Your writing is simple great, Especially for beginners!
I don't give a shite what you saw there, you need to come home, Bring your observations. Been too long for both of us. :::: smack , Smack . Who is she?
Dear Chuck!
You re definitely thinking right...
But there's forever have been storytelling.
People started telling stories even before they invented speech. They did it with drawings on the wall.
So what I d like to say, that's nice idea. Really nice. There's gotta be a place in each major city, when anytime you can get there and have some people listen to your story. Whether it's real or it's fiction. They would listen and then tell you what they think. And then you would listen to their stories.
It's like Internet but in real life.
So If you somehow will turn the idea in reality...I think it would be perfect for our society.
Thanks.
Arseniy.
CHUCK; if the government could grant us recognition of being an official religion, per say, FIRST CHURCH OF STORY, do you think we could instill the use of hallucinogens and fun narcotics as a necessary element of our story telling? Could facilitators or group leaders have 3 or maybe 5 wives? Just curious.